Weight control strategies of Olympic athletes striving for leanness: what can be done to make sport a safer environment?

M. Mountjoy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/JSM.0b013e3181635664

Abstract:‘‘The optimization of body weight and composition for a specific sport is a key priority in the elite athlete’s pursuit of competitive advantage.. At the same time, striving for leanness can result in impaired performance and negative health consequences if chronic energy deficiency develops.’’ Hagmar et al in their study ‘‘Special attention to the weight control strategies employed by Olympic athletes striving for leanness is required’’ (found elsewhere in these pages), provide scientific evidence of the serious health risks faced by Olympic athletes in their quest for leanness. As the team physician for an Olympic Synchronized swim team I review, with great interest, the scientific literature regarding the health risks of elite esthetic sports. It is well documented that the drive for body leanness can result in suboptimal athletic performance as well as significant health risks. The main goal of the IOC Medical Commission is to secure the good health of the athletes. In its role of promoting and protecting their health, the IOCMedical Commission is most interested in the weight control strategies employed by Olympic athletes. It is supporting the efforts of a Women’s Working Group that is examining ways to decrease the special health risks of athletes in sports where weight control is an issue. Hagmar and colleagues provide further scientific evidence of the need for this approach. In their investigation Hagmar and colleagues examined the weight control strategies utilized by by both male and female Olympic athletes from a variety of sport disciplines. Although there have been previous studies documenting the health consequences of a pursuit for leanness in elite sport and on the prevalence of eating disorders in elite sport, no study to date has compared, in both males and females, the incidence of such disorders and their relationship to training practices and self-perceived weight. This study thus provides the sport medicine community with valuable scientific evidence which will, hopefully, assist in providing further impetus for changes within the world of elite sport to ensure safer and healthier environments for athletes. Hagmar et al show that athletes in lean sports relative to non-lean sports: have lower mean BMI; have more pronounced variations in weight; train for longer hours; report higher training loads; make more frequent attempts to lose weight; weigh more than they desire; have a higher frequency of previous eating disorders; and report a significantly higher proportion of illness in the three months prior to an Olympic Games. These findings clearly demonstrate that athletes who train and compete in sports where leanness is important are at risk of harm to health and jeopardize optimal athletic performance. These findings are not surprising. The pressure on athletes to attain an ‘‘ideal’’ body composition emphasizing thinness in esthetic sports is tremendous. Practices such as team weigh-ins, disciplinary action for weight gain and team position being determined by body composition are but a few of the coaching tools that contribute to these statistics. The challenge now is to use this evidence and create change in order to bring about a more positive environment; an environment where the pressure to achieve thinness is eliminated. Noteworthy among their findings is the discrepancy between gender in lean versus non-lean sports with respect to BMI, variations in weight, attempts to lose weight, exercise