Erythropoietin N-glycosylation of Therapeutic Formulations Quantified and Characterized: An Interlab Comparability Study of High-Throughput Methods

Róisín O’Flaherty,Manuela Amez Martín,Richard A. Gardner,Patrick M. Jennings,Pauline M. Rudd,Daniel I. R. Spencer,David Falck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/biom14010125

IF: 6.064

2024-01-19

Biomolecules

Abstract:Recombinant human erythropoietin (EPO) is a biopharmaceutical frequently used in the treatment of anemia. It is a heavily glycosylated protein with a diverse and complex glycome. EPO N-glycosylation influences important pharmacological parameters, prominently serum half-life. Therefore, EPO N-glycosylation analysis is of the utmost importance in terms of controlling critical quality attributes. In this work, we performed an interlaboratory study of glycoanalytical techniques for profiling and in-depth characterization, namely (1) hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection after 2-aminobenzamide labeling (HILIC-FLD(2AB)) and optional weak anion exchange chromatography (WAX) fractionation and exoglycosidase digestion, (2) HILIC-FLD after procainamide labeling (PROC) optionally coupled to electrospray ionization-MS and (3) matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS). All techniques showed good precision and were able to differentiate the unique N-glycosylation profiles of the various EPO preparations. HILIC-FLD showed higher precision, while MALDI-TOF-MS covered the most analytes. However, HILIC-FLD differentiated isomeric N-glycans, i.e., N-acetyllactosamine repeats and O-acetylation regioisomers. For routine profiling, HILIC-FLD methods are more accessible and cover isomerism in major structures, while MALDI-MS covers more minor analytes with an attractively high throughput. For in-depth characterization, MALDI-MS and HILIC-FLD(2AB)/WAX give a similar amount of orthogonal information. HILIC-FLD(PROC)-MS is attractive for covering isomerism of major structures with a significantly less extensive workflow compared to HILIC-FLD(2AB)/WAX.

biochemistry & molecular biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the quantification and characterization of erythropoietin (EPO) N-glycosylation in therapeutic formulations and to evaluate the performance of different analytical techniques through an inter-laboratory comparability study using high-throughput methods.

Specifically, the study compares three different N-glycosylation analysis methods used to analyze EPO samples from three different sources (including first-generation, second-generation, and third-generation EPO products). The main objectives of the study are:

1. **Fingerprint Uniqueness and Reproducibility**: Generate unique fingerprints for each product and ensure high reproducibility.
2. **Structural Resolution**: Provide sufficient structural resolution to link spectral changes to functional characteristics.
3. **Comparability of Results Between Methods**: Focus on critical quality attributes (CQA) to ensure the results of different methods are comparable.

The study employed five methods for comparison:
- HILIC-FLD(2AB): Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography-fluorescence detection with or without weak anion exchange chromatography (WAX) fractionation and exoglycosidase digestion after 2-aminobenzamide labeling.
- HILIC-FLD(PROC): Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography-fluorescence detection with or without electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) after procainamide labeling.
- MALDI-MS: Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry.

The study found that all methods exhibited good precision and were able to distinguish the unique N-glycosylation profiles of various EPO formulations. Among them, HILIC-FLD showed better precision, while MALDI-MS covered a broader range of analytes. For routine spectral analysis, the HILIC-FLD method was more accessible and covered isomers in major structures; for in-depth characterization, MALDI-MS and HILIC-FLD(2AB)/WAX provided a similar amount of orthogonal information.