Apnoea in Anaesthesia

E. Pask

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/BMJ.1.4818.1048

1953-05-09

British Medical Journal

Abstract:SIR,-In your leading article (Journal, April 18, p. 875) on apnoea in anaesthesia the sting lies in the tail. The final sentence reads: " Further, the differential pressure changes occurring in the lungs and respiratory tract should not be such as to cause disturbance to the cardiovascular system." 1 believe that many physiologists will be surprised to learn that positive pressure ventilations can be carried out at all without causing some disturbance in the cardiovascular system. The disturbance is small, no doubt, usually well tolerated, and more than compensated by the other advantages of quiet, full ventilation which perhaps can in the particular circumstances be secured only by positive pressure inflation. Nevertheless there are still anaesthetists so old-fashioned as to believe that in certain cases the unavoidable slight disturbance of cardiovascular function consequent upon positive pressure inflation may become of critical importance. I believe that there are critically ill patients who do better if they are allowed to breathe for themselves, and it seems to me that it is the anaesthetist's business to balance the risks and pick these cases out. One often has to do a little harm in order to achieve more good, but it seems wrong to lose sight of the fact that the " little harm " is a real thing.I am, etc., Newcastle-upon-Tyne. E. A. PASK.