Nucleation mechanisms of molecular oxides: a study of the assembly-dissassembly of [W6O19]2- by theory and mass spectrometry.
Laia Vilà‐Nadal,A. Rodríguez‐Fortea,Likai Yan,Elizabeth F. Wilson,L. Cronin,J. Poblet
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.200901348
2009-07-13
Angewandte Chemie
Abstract:Polyoxometalates (POMs) are a vast class of polynuclear molecular oxide anions usually formed by W, Mo, or V. These clusters are interesting since their assembly through polymerized metal-based polyhedra can yield molecules that span the molecular to nanoparticle size range and form colloidal aggregates. This capacity to span large size ranges, coupled with their attractive electronic and molecular properties, gives rise to a variety of applications in diverse fields such as catalysis, medicine, and materials science. Despite the ever-increasing interest in this class of materials, accurate determination of the formula, structure, and building-block principles still represents a great challenge for understanding and exploiting cluster formation. To this end the use of electrospray mass spectrometry (ESIMS) to investigate POM systems, as a complementary technique to X-ray crystallography and NMR studies, has increased steadily over the last decade. Recently, Cronin and co-workers demonstrated that electrospray (ESI) and cryospray mass spectrometry (CSIMS) can be used as versatile tools in various complex systems to investigate the molecular oxide clusters in solution, allowing elucidation of the formula and providing insight into the “building-block” species present in solution. Considerable theoretical research concerning POMs has been carried out during the last decade, but only a few studies have been devoted to analysis of their mechanism of formation. Kepert, in the early 1960s, suggested that formation of POMs might involve the addition of WO4 tetrahedra. The first step would imply the addition of a WO4 unit, acting as a bidentate ligand, to a second WO4 unit by expanding the coordination number of the latter metal ion to six. Acidification of alkaline aqueous solutions of simple oxo anions is one of the most common preparative methods of POMs. After protonation, the W ion becomes more electrophilic and can be more effectively attacked by the nucleophilic O atoms of the [WO4] 2 anion. In the 1970s, Tytko and Glemser proposed elaborate mechanisms to explain the formation of POMs based on the Kepert addition process. There is, however, little experimental evidence to support these mechanisms. To the best of our knowledge, no other theoretical studies have attempted to elucidate the formation mechanisms of POMs. Only studies about the rates of oxygen exchange between the Lindqvist anion [HxM6O19] (8 x) (M = Nb, Ta) and aqueous solutions which show the reversibility of the M O bond breaking and formation are available. Herein, we aim to shed light on the formation mechanisms of POMs with low nuclearities, as is the case of the W-based Lindqvist anion [W6O19] 2 , under different pH conditions. To achieve this goal, we performed ESIMS experiments on [(C4H9)4N]2W6O19 [11] combined with computational techniques that include the effect of the solvent in two different ways, either through a continuum model in standard DFT methods or as explicit molecules by means of Car–Parrinello molecular-dynamics (MD) simulations. Since the ESIMS experiments can provide fragmentation data, the correlation between these data and the mechanistic details could provide important information if the species observed in the fragmentation process can be related to those generated in the formation of the POM cluster. To analyze the first step of the growth mechanism, we performed Car–Parrinello MD simulations. The metadynamics approach was used to accelerate the dynamics and to compute the free-energy barriers. Such a computational strategy has been already applied to the study of the hydration of hydrogentungstate anions under different pH conditions. The hydrogentungstate anion [WO3(OH)] is considered as the building block in our construction scheme as it is an abundant species under the conditions in which POMs are synthesized. We present a qualitative description of the events observed during an 11 ps metadynamics run of [*] L. Vil -Nadal, Dr. A. Rodr guez-Fortea, Dr. L.-K. Yan, Prof. Dr. J. M. Poblet Departament de Qu mica F sica i Inorg nica, Universitat Rovira i Virgili, c/Marcel· Domingo s/n, 43007 Tarragona (Spain) Fax: (+ 34)977-559-569 E-mail: antonio.rodriguezf@urv.cat josepmaria.poblet@urv.cat