STEVE DINHAM AND CATHERINE SCOTT 36 Background to the International Teacher 2000 Project
S. Dinham,C. Scott
Abstract:Recent international research has demonstrated a relationship between physical health and occupational status/level of appointment: people who hold higher level positions enjoy better physical health on average than those in lower positions. Researchers have speculated that this may be in part due to the lower levels of control exercised over pace and timetabling of work by those occupying lower positions. Poorer physical health is thus mediated by lower levels of mental wellbeing. Worldwide, many working in school education have experienced ‘control’ being taken away from them by rapid and constant educational change imposed from ‘the outside’. The pace and extent of change has varied across nations, and it can be predicted that its effects will also vary according to its intensity. The research reported here was conducted in four countries Australia, New Zealand, England and the United States of America and employed a sample of more than 2600 teachers and school executives at over 360 primary and secondary schools. Context in this case, country was found to be the most powerful predictor of overall career satisfaction, change in satisfaction and mental health, as measured by the General Health Questionnaire. This result is discussed in the light of levels of educational change experienced at each of the four sites. The level of position an individual held and type of school they worked in were found to be related to his/her satisfaction and mental wellbeing in some contexts, but not others. In this paper, we explore the reasons for these relationships, using insights gained from the general research on occupational status and health. STEVE DINHAM AND CATHERINE SCOTT 36 Background to the International Teacher 2000 Project Public interest and involvement in education in many countries has been intensifying for several decades. If ever there was an ‘ivory tower’ of education, it has certainly begun to crumble as various pressure groups and stakeholders have attempted to shape and ‘measure’ what happens in schools, particularly state schools. Like all change, educational change has produced intended and unintended consequences. Some of the new expectations and responsibilities placed on schools and some of the imposed changes have been reasonable and even overdue, while others have been intrusive and potentially damaging. The International Teacher 2000 Project sought to address the issue of how, in the context of rapid and continuing educational change, teachers and school executives in several countries feel about their work. Participants were asked a number of key questions: 1. Why do teachers enter teaching? 2. How do teachers feel about teaching? 3. How do teachers feel they are regarded by their employer and society generally? 4. What aspects of their role do teachers find satisfying? 5. What do teachers find dissatisfying? 6. Are satisfaction levels changing? 7. Is teacher pre-service and in-service training adequate to meet the needs of the teachers of today and tomorrow? 8. How are teachers coping with change and the pressures being placed upon them? The International Teacher 2000 Project was undertaken because of a desire to answer the above questions and to benchmark teacher and executive satisfaction and mental health levels, so that more informed decision making could occur. The project was designed to extend and test the findings of previous interview-based research regarding teacher resignation (Dinham 1992); the impact of teaching on teachers and their partners (Dinham 1997); and the manifestations and implications of the ageing teacher population (Dinham 1996). The initial Australian phase of the project involved teachers and school executives at government schools in Western Sydney, and was completed in 1997 (Dinham & Scott 1996a; 1996b; 1997; 1998b). As a result of interest in this PRESSURE POINTS: SCHOOL EXECUTIVE AND EDUCATIONAL CHANGE 37 work and the desire to obtain comparative data, replications were launched in 1997 in England (Nottingham Trent University) and New Zealand (Massey University), while another replication began in 1998 in the United States of America (USA) (through Rowan University, New Jersey). Further replications are taking place in Malta, Canada and a number of other countries. Position held and health Recent international research has demonstrated a relationship between physical health and occupational status/level of appointment: persons who hold higher level positions in organisations enjoy better physical health on average than those in lower positions. Researchers have speculated that this may be in part due to the fact that individuals occupying lower positions have less control over the pace and allocation of their work than those occupying higher positions in the workplace (see Marmot & Theorell 1988; Marmot & Feeney 1996; Marmot et al 1997). Poorer physical health is thus mediated by lower levels of mental well being. Internationally, many of those working in school education have experienced ‘control’ being taken from them by rapid and constant educational change imposed from ‘the outside’ and ‘above’, as education has become increasingly politicised and open to external scrutiny and involvement by various stakeholders. The pace and extent of this change has varied across nations and it can be predicted that its effects will also vary according to its intensity and scope. In this paper, we explore the differences in overall occupational satisfaction and mental stress, and changes in satisfaction over time, for those occupying different promotion positions in different schools. As the effects of educational change vary not only across different positions but in different contexts, variations between countries are also explored using the four samples from Australia, New Zealand, England and the US. The relationship between satisfaction with school leadership and overall satisfaction is also briefly explored, of interest because it can be predicted that a ‘trickle down effect’ exists, by which school leaders who are themselves not ‘doing well’ may find it more difficult to provide effective leadership. Method Instrument The instruments used in the study were parallel versions of a machine readable self-report questionnaire. Minor changes were made to the original Australian version, to make wording of items consistent with terminology employed in the English, New Zealand and US contexts. A detailed description of methodology may be found elsewhere (Dinham & Scott 1996b; 1998a). The instrument contained the following demographic items: STEVE DINHAM AND CATHERINE SCOTT 38 • seven ‘orientation to teaching’ and two ‘preparedness to teach’ items (true/false); • 75 ‘satisfaction/dissatisfaction with teaching’ items (seven-point Likert scales); • two Likert scale items (with seven points each) to measure overall satisfaction and change in satisfaction since beginning teaching; • the Commitments scale (40-item version Novacek & Lazarus 1990); • the 12-item form of the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ), used as a measure of mental distress/stress; and • several opportunities for individuals to make open-ended comments. The 75 satisfaction items were used to calculate ten scales in the Australian, English and New Zealand cases; and 16 scales in the US cases, which measured satisfaction with aspects of teaching and their contexts. The development of the scales is described elsewhere (Dinham & Scott 1999b; 2000). Data from completed surveys were computer scanned and analysed using SPSS, while open-ended responses were subject to content analysis using NUDIST (Qualitative Solutions and Research Pty Ltd 1994). Participants Sampling Separate teams undertook the project in each country,1 and sampling methods employed by the four teams were varied to suit each local context. Below is a brief description of the sampling methods employed. A more detailed description may be found in previous publications (eg Dinham & Scott 1999). Australia The Australian sample was obtained from among teachers and school executives in the Metropolitan West Region, formerly one of the largest of the 10 regions in the public school system of the New South Wales Department of School Education (DSE), which employs over 50 000 teachers in total.2 Western Sydney was chosen because it was accessible and because of its heterogeneity. An invitation to participate was made to the principals of over one PRESSURE POINTS: SCHOOL EXECUTIVE AND EDUCATIONAL CHANGE 39 third of government schools in the region, ensuring a representative sample of schools. Overall, 47 of the region’s 185 primary schools, 19 of 54 secondary schools, and five of the region’s 16 Schools for Specific Purposes took part, with 2336 surveys distributed to the 71 schools. England Schools were selected by taking every fifth school appearing in the lists of eight local education authorities. In all, 661 schools were approached and 114 head teachers (principals) consented to participate. A total of 2384 questionnaires were posted to participating schools. New Zealand A stratified, random cluster sample was drawn, with the objective of obtaining at least 300 primary and at least 300 secondary teachers. Sampling frames were lists of all state and integrated primary schools (including intermediate schools), and all state and integrated secondary schools in the southern half of the North Island of New Zealand. USA US data were collected from public schools in the state of New Jersey. New Jersey was chosen because it has 609 school districts (more than any other state), yet it is one of the smallest states. It also contains a wide range of schools and, whilst many school districts appear to be suburban-like, these experience many of the problems of inner-city school districts. There are also many ‘one building’ school districts, with as few as 100 students in the entire district. The study was designed as a systematic random sample, stratified by cou