Abstract:Assisted reproduction techniques (ARTs) have given rise to novel, non-traditional family models. Still, among the various applications and approaches of 'medically assisted procreation' (MAP), the most divisive one undoubtedly is 'gestational surrogacy' (GS), also in light of the rising number of couples who have chosen it over the past twenty years. Another major implication of ARTs is the creation of intentional (or intended) parenthood in addition to genetic one: the genetic parent's partner is thus defined as the intentional (or second) parent, who by free choice, shares the family project with the genetic parent, even without any biological tie with the child. Hence, the intended parent takes on the same rights and responsibilities towards the child as the biological one. Several countries, including Italy, have enacted norms to discourage cross-border surrogacy, deeming it harmful to the dignity of women and children. Recently, however, the Italian government has decided intensify the fight against this practice: the Chamber of Deputies (Italy's lower chamber of parliament) has passed a law which punishes couples that resort to surrogacy even if the agreement and the birth take place abroad. Therefore, surrogacy would become a so-called universal crime. In light of the fact that criminalization is a serious and highly consequential step, which may have life-changing consequences for the intended parents, the aim of this paper is to assess whether this may be an effective instrument for regulating the interests at stake and, therefore, whether it would be desirable for other countries to follow such a model. Ultimately, it is worth remarking that for those who seek to achieve parenthood, such a desire is among the most profound aspects of a person's existential realization. When due to a delicate balance of ethics standards and potentially conflicting rights, lawmakers inter-vene, an authoritarian approach is unlikely to be beneficial. Offering real alternatives to surrogacy in an organic and pragmatic fashion (i.e. expediting adoption procedures, favoring motherhood at a younger age, when infertility issues are less likely to have set in) may be the best way to disincentivize fertility traveling and make sure the rights, hopes and aspirations of all the parties involved are upheld properly.

[Pre-conception sex selection]

Chinese geneticists' views of ethical issues in genetic testing and screening: evidence for eugenics in China

Ethical considerations in sex selection

Preconception Gender Selection

Sex selection and the procreative liberty framework

Selecting Sex: the Effect of Preferring Sons.

Islamic Viewpoints on Opportunistic Sex Selection of IVF Embryos upon doing Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Preventing Genetic Diseases

Reproduction opportunists in the new global sex trade: PGD and non-medical sex selection

Regulating Preimplantation Genetic Testing across the World: A Comparison of International Policy and Ethical Perspectives

Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Polygenetic Conditions: A Legal, Ethical, and Scientific Challenge

The right to be born: surrogacy and the legal control of human fertility

Assisted human reproduction legislation: Acknowledging the voice of health care professionals

Ethical and legal challenges in assisted same-sex conception through in vitro gametogenesis

Reconciling moral discourses on choice, risk and pronatalism: the politics of elective egg freezing in Singapore

Abnormal Sex Ratios in Human Populations: Causes and Consequences.

Infertility in Jewish couples, biblical and rabbinic law

Parents' 'fault' must not weigh on their children. Surrogacy as a universal crime in Italy: Is it compatible with bioethical principles?

Heritable human genome editing: correction, selection and treatment

Procreative rights denied? Access to assisted reproduction technologies by single women in China

The March 2021 Italian constitutional court ruling on surrogacy: a prelude to common European legislation for the sake of reproductive health?

The feasibility of premarital genetic screening laws