Abstract:Inventory and characterization schemes play different roles in shaping a variety of footprint indicators. This paper performs a systematic and critical investigation of the hidden inventory aspect and characterization aspect of selected footprints with implications for classification and integration of those footprints. It shows that all of the carbon, water, land and material footprints have two fundamentally distinct versions, addressing the environmental exchange of substances in terms of emissions and/or extractions either at the inventory level or at the impact assessment level. We therefore differentiate two broad categories of footprints, namely the inventory-oriented footprints and the impact-oriented footprints. The former allow for a physical interpretation of human pressure by inventorying emissions and extractions and aggregating them with value-based weighting factors, whereas the latter assess and aggregate the inventory results according to their potential contributions to a specific environmental impact using science-based characterization factors, with the recognition that these contributing substances are too different to be compared by mass, volume or area. While both categories have individual strengths and weaknesses, the impact-oriented footprints have a better performance than the inventory-oriented footprints on the integration of footprints into a single-score metric in support of policy making. Resembling the general procedure for life cycle impact assessment, we formulate a three-step framework for characterization, normalization and weighting of a set of impact-oriented footprints to yield a composite footprint index, which would allow policy makers to better assess the overall environmental impacts of entities at multiple scales ranging from single products, organizations, nations, even to the whole economy. The main value added of this paper is the establishment of a unified framework for structuring, categorizing and integrating different footprints. It may serve as a starting point for clearing the footprint jungle and for facilitating the ongoing discourse on a truly integrated footprint family.

Footprint analysis and the incidence of emission taxes

Carbon Footprint of Nations: A Global, Trade-Linked Analysis

Challenges in measuring the distribution of carbon footprints: The role of product and price heterogeneity

Give and take: An analysis of the distributional consequences of emission tax-and-rebate schemes with an application to greenhouse gas emissions from European agriculture

Gathering Support for Green Tax Reform: Evidence from German Household Surveys

Tracing two decades of carbon emissions using a network approach

Economic impact of the carbon tax: Evaluation of the reduction in CO2 emissions

Unequal carbon tax impacts on 38 million German households: assessing spatial and socio-economic hotspots

The Effect of Carbon Pricing on Firm Emissions: Evidence from the Swedish CO2 Tax

Nonequilibrium Thermodynamics in Measuring Carbon Footprints: Disentangling Structure and Artifact in Input-Output Accounting

Economic inequality and the ecological footprint: Time-varying estimates for four developed economies, 1962–2021

Environmentally related taxes and their influence on decarbonization of the economy

Investigating the Inventory and Characterization Aspects of Footprinting Methods: Lessons for the Classification and Integration of Footprints

Tracing carbon dioxide emissions in the European electricity markets

Quantile-based effect of energy, transport, and total environmental tax on ecological footprint in EU5 countries

INPUT–OUTPUT ANALYSIS AND CARBON FOOTPRINTING: AN OVERVIEW OF APPLICATIONS

Mitigating Carbon Leakage: Combining Output-Based Rebating with a Consumption Tax

Distributional Effects of a European Carbon Tax

Distributional Effects of Climate Change Taxation: the Case of the UK.

Using Energy and Emissions Taxation to Finance Labor Tax Reductions in a Multi-Sector Economy: An Assessment with Emuse