Room-Temperature Plastic Deformation in Diamond Nanopillars
Jon Fuller,Qi An
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matt.2020.04.003
IF: 18.9
2020-01-01
Matter
Abstract:Diamond, which was previously believed to exhibit almost no plasticity at room temperature, has been found to exhibit limited plastic behavior by compressing diamond nanopillars and analyzing the resulting dislocation behavior through combined experimental and theoretical studies. Diamond, which was previously believed to exhibit almost no plasticity at room temperature, has been found to exhibit limited plastic behavior by compressing diamond nanopillars and analyzing the resulting dislocation behavior through combined experimental and theoretical studies. Diamond is a remarkable material with many desirable properties that make it uniquely well suited for various applications in both scientific fields and industry. Well known as one of the hardest substances discovered so far, and indeed the hardest crystalline solid,1Huang Q. Yu D. Xu B. Hu W. Ma Y. Wang Y. Zhao Z. Wen B. He J. Liu Z. Tian Y. Nanotwinned diamond with unprecedented hardness and stability.Nature. 2014; 510: 250-253Crossref PubMed Scopus (516) Google Scholar diamond owes its remarkable strength and hardness to an interesting combination of the strongest type of inter-atomic bonding, covalent bonds,2Kalescky R. Kraka E. Cremer D. Identification of the strongest bonds in chemistry.J. Phys. Chem. A. 2013; 117: 8981-8995Crossref PubMed Scopus (113) Google Scholar and a cubic structure that is highly symmetrical. This strength comes at a price, however, as the incredibly strong covalent bonds and symmetrical crystal lattice of diamond allow for it to easily shear smoothly in multiple directions, resulting in a high degree of brittleness that interferes with its desired applications in the aforementioned fields. It has been previously believed due to results of both experimental and theoretical studies that diamond cannot exhibit plasticity (the ability to deform permanently without fracturing) at room temperature. Researchers have attempted to determine both the elastic and plastic deformation capabilities of diamond nanostructures through a variety of methods in recent years,2Kalescky R. Kraka E. Cremer D. Identification of the strongest bonds in chemistry.J. Phys. Chem. A. 2013; 117: 8981-8995Crossref PubMed Scopus (113) Google Scholar,3Banerjee A. Bernoulli D. Zhang H. Yuen M.F. Liu J. Dong J. Ding F. Lu J. Dao M. Zhang W. et al.Ultralarge elastic deformation of nanoscale diamond.Science. 2018; 360: 300-302Crossref PubMed Scopus (163) Google Scholar and a paper in Matter4LLorca J. On the quest for the strongest materials.Science. 2018; 360: 264-265Crossref PubMed Scopus (7) Google Scholar has published results indicating that plastic deformation free of brittle fracturing under stress can be induced in diamond nanopillars using nanoscale compression along low-index crystallographic directions. Diamond is composed of carbon atoms locked in a rigid lattice, equally distant from each other and engaged in covalent bonding with their neighbors. Covalent bonding involves the equivalent sharing of the electrons engaged in bonding between the carbons; since each carbon atom has four valence electrons, they can each bond in this manner with four adjacent carbon atoms. The result is a cubic crystal system (shown in Figure 1A) that exhibits impressive strength and hardness and a very high melting temperature due to the regularity of the bond distance and arrangement of the constituent carbon atoms. Due to these strong covalent bonds, diamond is also both a good conductor of heat and a very poor electrical conductor. The promising mechanical properties of diamond are highly desirable in specific research and industrial applications, where high temperature and pressures are present and significant strength and durability is needed to withstand working conditions. However, these benefits derived from the diamond system come with a heavy drawback. Since diamond is so unyieldingly strong, and due to the uniformity of the evenly spaced carbon atoms within, it is highly vulnerable to brittle cracking under sustained pressure or impact. Diamond is found to have relatively poor toughness compared to common materials used for its desired applications, such as high-strength steels; this is primarily due to the aforementioned highly symmetrical cubic structure, which allows for cleavage under applied stress along four planes, leaving perfectly smooth surfaces behind. It is relatively well-known that diamond generally fractures along the (111) plane (shown in Figure 1A) due to its lower fracture energy compared to the other planes.3Banerjee A. Bernoulli D. Zhang H. Yuen M.F. Liu J. Dong J. Ding F. Lu J. Dao M. Zhang W. et al.Ultralarge elastic deformation of nanoscale diamond.Science. 2018; 360: 300-302Crossref PubMed Scopus (163) Google Scholar This brittleness can be mitigated at higher temperatures and pressures where diamond is found to begin exhibiting plastic behavior instead of fracturing along octahedral cleavage planes5Nie A. Bu Y. Huang J. Shao Y. Zhang Y. Hu W. Liu J. Wang Y. Xu B. Liu Z. et al.Direct Observation of Room-Temperature Dislocation Plasticity in Diamond.Matter. 2020; 2 (this issue): 1222-1232Scopus (29) Google Scholar as is typical at room temperature and pressure. This plastic deformation behavior, commonly known as “plasticity,” refers to the ability of a specific material to deform without fracturing and is highly desirable for a variety of applications where the material is subjected to repeated mechanical stresses. Plastic deformation in metals or other crystalline materials in a general sense describes the flow of dislocations, or generally, that metals (which engage in the much more flexible metallic bonding due to the sharing of their electrons in a delocalized cloud rather than in a one-to-one exchange such as a covalent bond) are found to exhibit increased plasticity as temperature is elevated and considerably more limited plasticity at room temperature. Since diamond consists of extremely strong covalent bonds between carbon atoms, however, it has traditionally been understood that the material can only exhibit plasticity at high temperature. The high temperature is found to significantly “soften” diamond, allowing it to deform plastically; however, these conditions are difficult to achieve and maintain in the desired applications, and the uncontrolled deformation of diamond during them leads to undesirable mechanical properties for many applications where the hardness of diamond is specifically desired. Therefore, the mechanisms of fracture and deformation have been an area of significant interest in recent years for researchers to obtain a better understanding of how plasticity can be induced in diamond to make it more viable for a wider range of applications demanding extreme strength and hardness. Most theoretical and experimental studies on diamond have previously indicated that it shows almost no plastic behavior at room temperature.6Fung K.Y. Tang C.Y. Cheung C.F. Law W.C. Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Plastic Deformation of Diamond at an Elevated Temperature.Key Eng. Mater. 2015; 626: 329-333Crossref Scopus (4) Google Scholar However, Nie et al. recently demonstrated that diamond can facilitate the slip of dislocations plastically at room temperature by applying compressive force along low-index crystallographic directions in diamond nanopillars. This challenges the previously understood behavior of diamond at the nano scale and has important implications in determining the mechanical properties of diamond for many useful applications. To achieve this, Nie et al. employed a micrometers-thin diamond sheet cut from a monocrystal and processed into a milled set of diamond nanopillars using the focused ion beam (FIB) method, in which a beam of charged ions is employed to cut and shape the surface for experimental purposes. The sheet of these diamond nanopillars was then subjected to stress applied by a diamond nanoindenter pressed against their surface, with transmission electron microscope (TEM) imaging employed to analyze the formation and behavior of the resulting dislocations in the diamond. They found that the nanopillars exhibited plastic deformation when this compression was applied on both < 111 > and < 110 > directions, leading to dislocation slip along the {001} family of non-close-packed planes. The dislocation half-loops for these directions are shown in Figures 1B and 1C. Dislocations in the closely packed {111} family of planes were found to result from compressive stress along < 100 > oriented pillars. This indicates the significant discovery that the slip of dislocations in diamond are dependent on the direction of the applied stress, with the {001} planes dominating the slip process in contrast to prior research, which indicated that the {111} planes should play the most important role in face-centered cubic (FCC) materials at room temperature.7Field J.E. Freeman C.J. Strength and fracture properties of diamond.Philos. Mag. A. 1981; 43: 595-618Crossref Scopus (45) Google Scholar,8Frick C.P. Clark B.G. Orso S. Schneider A.S. Artz E. Size effect on strength and strain hardening of small-scale [111] nickel compression pillars.Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2008; 489: 319-329Crossref Scopus (328) Google Scholar To better understand this slip behavior in the {001} planes, Nie et al. devised a molecular dynamics simulation using density functional tight binding (DFTB) method to simulate a 794-atom system of carbon atoms arranged in the diamond lattice structure with an introduced edge dislocation (a series of extra atoms arrayed in a line that is placed in the lattice to simulate a dislocation). This system was then subjected to a simulated shear strain similar to what would be experienced by the diamond nanopillars under the experimental conditions as the compressive stress was applied and then allowed to relax. A continuous dislocation motion was found to exist during repeated simulations, indicating that the slip systems identified in the experimental work are correct and dominant for the dislocation motion. The results of this study significantly impact our understanding of the behavior of dislocation slip and plasticity in extremely brittle covalent crystal systems. By better understanding the plastic deformation mechanisms postulated here, and particularly the importance of the {001} slip planes in plastic deformation, future experimental and theoretical research can be devised to investigate methods of more universally inducing plastic deformation instead of fractures under stress in diamond and other covalent crystals, such as silicon carbide or boron carbide,9An Q. Goddard 3rd, W.A. Atomistic Origin of Brittle Failure of Boron Carbide from Large-Scale Reactive Dynamics Simulations: Suggestions toward Improved Ductility.Phys. Rev. Lett. 2015; 115: 105501Crossref PubMed Scopus (106) Google Scholar increasing their viability in applications that require a high degree of toughness in addition to strength and hardness. This is very important for the applications where the strength of diamond is highly favorable, such as in industrial diamond tools for cutting or processing other materials such as metals. Additionally, the techniques devised here, particularly the in situ TEM methods for analyzing the dislocation slip, can be applied to other highly brittle crystalline materials, which will allow researchers to analyze systems that have previously proven very difficult to work with. It will prove very interesting to see future research in this area focusing on the mechanism of plastic deformation at or near room temperatures in other brittle covalent crystals and eventually research to find methods of controlling the applied stress in various applications in order to take advantage of the previously unproven room temperature plasticity of diamond. This work was supported by National Science Foundation (CMMI-1727428). Direct Observation of Room-Temperature Dislocation Plasticity in DiamondNie et al.MatterMarch 10, 2020In BriefThe orientation-dependent dislocation behaviors observed in diamond, especially generation in the non-close-packed {001} planes, stimulate reconsideration of the basic deformation mechanism of the brittle covalent crystals at low temperatures. Full-Text PDF Open Archive