Abstract:We have read with great interest the letter from Dr. Leal-Noval et al. regarding our paper. They raise several questions we are pleased to provide answers.In the TRAHT study [<a href="#CR1">1</a>], the mean hemoglobin concentration during the first 14 days after hospital admission was 9.3 ± 1.3 g/dL in the liberal group and 8.4 ± 1.0 g/dL in the restrictive group (p p <a href="#CR6">6</a>].The TRAHT study was a randomized clinical trial, meaning the only difference between groups after randomization was the transfusion strategy. After randomization, the patients in the liberal group receive a total of 66 red blood cells (RBCs) units as compared with 35 RBC units in the restrictive group (p = 0.02), with a good protocol adherence. However, the sample size was small, which may have led to unbalanced groups. The restrictive group had more pupil alterations and more midline deviation ≥ 5 mm on brain CT, and more patients received blood transfusions before randomization compared to the liberal group 9 (43%) vs. 15 (65%), respectively. Nevertheless, the study groups were statistically well matched at baseline with respect to demographic and clinical characteristics. Although not statistically significant, it might suggest that the restrictive group would be more severely injured than the liberal group and this could explain part of the reported secondary outcomes.Several experimental, physiological, and observational data point toward an increase in the brain tissue oxygen partial pressure (PbtO2) in anemic neurocritical patients that received RBC transfusion [<a href="#CR7">7</a>]. If these results translate into better patient-centered outcomes, whether PbtO2 could be used to identify the patients which benefit from RBC transfusion remains to be determined.Anemia as well as RBC transfusion is associated with worse outcomes in TBI patients [<a href="#CR8">8</a>, <a href="#CR9">9</a>]. However, these data come from observational trials which are deeply susceptible to confusion bias, even after statistical analysis of the data and are particularly influenced by the patients' severity. The most severe TBI patients are anemic, and the most severe anemic TBI patients receive blood transfusion. Thus, TBI patients receiving blood transfusion would be always associated with worse outcomes in this setting. Therefore, only an adequately powered randomized clinical trial could answer the question if a strategy aimed at correcting anemia by RBC transfusion could benefit severe TBI patients. TRAHT was a pilot trial, aimed at evaluating the feasibility of a randomized clinical trial comparing liberal and restrictive blood transfusion strategies in patients with moderate and severe TBI. Although its secondary analysis in favor of the liberal transfusion strategy was noteworthy, we agree that the study results should be interpreted cautiously.

Red blood cell transfusion in neurosurgical patients

Anemia and red blood cell transfusion in neurocritical care

Red blood cell transfusion in neurocritical patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Blood transfusion indications in neurosurgical patients: A systematic review

Red blood cell transfusion in neurosurgery

Red blood cell transfusion in patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage: a multidisciplinary North American survey

Anemia management after acute brain injury

Red Blood Cell Transfusion and Transfusion Alternatives in Traumatic Brain Injury

Anemia and Red Blood Cell Transfusion in Aneurysmal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage

Anemia in the setting of traumatic brain injury: the arguments for and against liberal transfusion

Red blood cell transfusion may be more detrimental than anemia for the clinical outcome of patients with severe traumatic brain injury

The Effects of Red Blood Cell Transfusion on Functional Outcome after Aneurysmal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage

Restrictive and liberal red cell transfusion strategies in adult patients: reconciling clinical data with best practice

Effect of Peri-operative Blood Transfusion on Neurological Outcome Following Aneurysmal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: A Prospective Observational Study

Red Blood Cell Transfusions Are Not Associated With Incident Complications or Poor Outcomes in Patients With Intracerebral Hemorrhage

Transfusion practices for acute traumatic brain injury: a survey of physicians at US trauma centers

Transfusion Frequency of Red Blood Cells, Fresh Frozen Plasma, and Platelets During Ruptured Cerebral Aneurysm Surgery

The choice of blood transfusion strategy in severe traumatic brain injury

Hemoglobin levels and transfusions in neurocritically ill patients: a systematic review of comparative studies

Red Blood Cell Transfusion in Critically Ill Adults: An American College of Chest Physicians Clinical Practice Guideline

Red blood cell transfusion is associated with infection and extracerebral complications after subarachnoid hemorrhage