The parenthood effect in urban mobility

Mariana Macedo,Ronaldo Menezes,Alessio Cardillo

2025-01-04

Abstract:The modelling of human mobility is vital for the understanding of the complexity of urban dynamics and guiding effective interventions to improve quality of life. Traditional modelling approaches focus on `average citizens,' which overlook the multitude of experiences from distinct sociodemographic groups. Recent studies have unveiled significant variations in mobility patterns related to gender and socioeconomic status, yet the impact of parenthood remains under-explored. Parenthood brings profound changes to daily routines, influenced by factors such as increased caregiving responsibilities, altered work-life balance, and the need for family-friendly environments. Parents often prioritise considerations such as cost of living, social wellbeing, environmental quality, and safety. Quantifying how `friendly' a city is becomes more and more important for parents, especially in the context of rising remote work opportunities which, in turn, reverberate on the choices on where to settle. This work investigates whether these considerations lead to distinct mobility patterns between parents and non-parents, also accounting for the impact of partnership. Using extensive census data across American cities, we analyse how parenthood and partnership reshape their urban experiences. Our findings indicate that cities can indeed be classified by their level of friendliness towards parents and partners. For example, Dallas and Nashville can be more suited for single individuals, New York and Chicago can be more accommodating to parents, while Washington and Baltimore favour married people. These insights contribute to the growing body of research advocating for more nuanced and equitable urban planning. By recognising the diverse needs of different demographic groups, particularly parents, our study underscores the importance of tailored urban design strategies over universal solutions.

Physics and Society,Information Theory,Data Analysis, Statistics and Probability

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore the influence of parenthood and partnership on the mobility patterns of urban residents. Specifically, the authors attempt to answer the following key questions:

1. **How do parenthood and partnership affect the mobility patterns of urban residents?**
- Parenthood and partnership are major events in life, and these changes will profoundly alter an individual's daily activities, the distribution of responsibilities, and the way of interacting with the environment. For example, parents may be more inclined to choose a place of residence close to facilities such as schools and nurseries, while partnership may lead to changes in housing needs (such as a larger house, dual - income families, etc.). These issues become more complicated in the context of increased opportunities for remote work.

2. **What are the differences in the friendliness of different cities to parents and partner groups?**
- By analyzing detailed census data from multiple cities in the United States, researchers attempt to determine which cities are more suitable for parents or single people to live in. For example, New York and Chicago may be more suitable for families with children, while Dallas and Nashville may be more suitable for single people. This classification helps to understand the differences in planning and infrastructure construction in different cities.

3. **Are these differences statistically significant and can they provide guidance for urban planning?**
- Researchers not only describe these differences but also verify through multiple null models whether these differences are merely the result of random noise. The results show that parenthood and partnership do have a substantial impact on mobility patterns, and these impacts are not the product of a random process.

4. **How can urban planning and policy interventions be used to improve the urban experience of different groups?**
- The research results indicate that urban planning needs to consider the needs of different sociodemographic groups more carefully. For example, providing better transportation and living conditions for parents can reduce their commuting time and economic burden; providing more areas suitable for family life for married couples can improve their quality of life. These findings provide a basis for formulating more equitable and effective urban planning strategies.

### Summary

In general, through detailed data analysis and model verification, this paper reveals the important influence of parenthood and partnership on the mobility patterns of urban residents and proposes suggestions for personalized urban planning for different groups. This not only helps to improve the overall livability of the city but also promotes social equity and sustainable development.