The Effectiveness of Student-Led Ward Round Training on Knowledge Acquisition, Critical Thinking Ability, and Self-Confidence of Acute Upper Gastrointestinal Bleeding for Nursing Students
Nan Liu,Ziyu Zheng,Jinli Liao,Jiaxin Li,Zhen Yang,Xiaojuan Lai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/AMEP.S381760
2023-01-08
Advances in Medical Education and Practice
Abstract:Nan Liu, &ast Ziyu Zheng, &ast Jinli Liao, &ast Jiaxin Li, Zhen Yang, Xiaojuan Lai Department of Emergency Medicine, the First Affiliated Hospital, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, 510080, People's Republic of China &astThese authors contributed equally to this work Correspondence: Xiaojuan Lai; Zhen Yang, Email ; Introduction: Nursing knowledge, critical thinking ability, and self-perceived confidence are imperative to nursing skills in professional nursing practice. Therefore, nurse educators are required to use teaching strategies that will help promote their knowledge, critical thinking, and self-confidence in complex contents such as the nursing of acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding (AUGIB). Purpose: This study compares the effect of student-led and instructor-led ward-round training methods on knowledge acquisition, critical thinking ability, and self-perceived confidence during AUGIB sessions. Methods: Forty nursing students in the first year of the Emergency Nursing Residency Program were randomly divided into a student-led ward round training group (SG) and an instructor-led ward round training group (IG) with a ratio of 1:1. A knowledge quiz, critical thinking ability test, and self-perceived confidence questionnaire were performed before and after the ward round training to assess both groups of students for their knowledge acquisition, critical thinking ability, and self-perceived confidence improvement. Feedback questionnaires were conducted after the training to evaluate students' perspectives and interests concerning the teaching module. Results: The scores of the post-training quiz were significantly higher than that of the pre-training quiz in both the SG (44.10± 2.92 vs 31.10± 4.27, p< 0.001) and IG (32.35± 2.21 vs 30.55± 2.24, p=0.01). In the post-training quiz, scores achieved by the students from the SG (44.10± 2.92) were significantly higher than those achieved by the students from the IG (32.35± 2.21, p< 0.001). The level of self-perceived confidence improved significantly after ward round training in the SG (p< 0.001). However, there was no statistically significant difference in the IG with respect to the change from pre- to post-training (p=0.43).The students' critical thinking ability improved significantly in the SG (14.95± 2.58 vs 7.10± 1.79, p< 0.001), while no significant improvement was found in the IG (7.91± 2.28 vs 6.52± 2.21, p=0.07) after ward round training. Conclusion: The teaching method of SWRT improves nursing students' knowledge acquisition, critical thinking ability, and self-perceived confidence in AUGIB. Keywords: student-led ward round training, knowledge acquisition, critical thinking ability, self-perceived confidence, nursing education Patients' outcomes were determined not only by medical staff's professional knowledge, by also related to their critical nontechnical skills, such as critical thinking ability (CTA), self-perceived confidence (SC), communication skills and teamwork ability. 1 Conducting a ward round is a complex and multifactorial process requiring both medical expertise and nontechnical skills. 2,3 Therefore, ward-round teaching has been used to improve students' quality of patient assessment, management, and nontechnical skills in medical education. 2,4–6 However, there are limited studies on nursing education through ward-round training. 7–10 Acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding (AUGIB) is one of the most common emergency visits in China. The incidence of AUGIB is 37–172/10,000 adults, with a crude overall in-hospital mortality of 10%. 11,12 Therefore, AUGIB is a core component of the medical curriculum from the Emergency Nursing Residency Program (ENRP) designed by the Teaching and Research Office of Emergency Department (TRO-ED), First Affiliated Hospital (FAH), Sun Yat-sen University (SYSU). In recent years, the teaching of AUGIB was conducted with the method of instructor-led ward round training (IWRT). However, according to a previous survey conducted by the TRO-ED, notable shortcomings of this teaching method in students' SC improvement, independence in learning, understanding, and acquisition of knowledge were reported by students and instructors. Therefore, an urgent call for teaching reform was sent out by the TRO-ED. Student-, or peer-led learning, is one of the instructional activities that encourage greater autonomy and collaboration between students. In nursing education, the student-led educational module has shown promising effects for promoting self-directed learning and preparing nurses with the required medical knowledge and skills to support effective patient care and outcomes. 13–15 T -Abstract Truncated-