The Impact of CSR Implement Modes on Sustainable Supply Chain Pricing and Green Decision Making

Wenxia Li,Linzhong Liu,Zhuo Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16125269

IF: 3.9

2024-06-21

Sustainability

Abstract:Green transformation is an effective way for supply chains to achieve sustainable development. In the heterogeneous substitute product coexistence environment, it is valuable to explore the motivation behind CSR implementation as well as the advantages and differences associated with different members' CSR implementations. In this study, we consider that the manufacturer produces both green products and ordinary products that are substitutes for each other and construct a CSR-absence scenario (Model N), a retailer implementing CSR scenario (Model R), and a manufacturer implementing CSR scenario (Model M). Applying a game-theory-based method, we obtain the optimal pricing, green decision, and supply chain profit under different scenarios. We analyze the effects of consumers' green preference, green product function coefficient, and CSR level on decision making and performance. Through comparison and numerical analysis, we find the following: (1) Although the CSR behaviors of the manufacturer and the retailer squeeze the market demand space of the ordinary products, the greenness of the green product increases, and the retail price decreases. This not only enhances the consumer surplus of green products but also increases the profit and social welfare of the supply chain system. (2) The eco-friendliness of green products, product demand, and social welfare levels are the highest when the retailer implements CSR, followed by when the manufacturer implements CSR, and are the lowest in the CSR-absence scenario. In addition, the following retailer can enhance both its and the manufacturer's profits through implementing CSR within a reasonable range. (3) The numerical analysis results show that, when the functional attributes of the green products meet a certain level, supply chain members implementing CSR does not affect consumers' choice of green products.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the impact of different models of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) implementation on product pricing and green decisions in a sustainable supply chain. Specifically, the study constructs a two-tier supply chain model that includes manufacturers and retailers, where manufacturers produce two types of substitutable goods: green products and regular products.

The paper attempts to address the following key questions:
1. How does the implementation of CSR by different members affect the pricing, greenness, and market share of heterogeneous products, compared to scenarios without CSR implementation?
2. How should different enterprises implementing CSR set their CSR implementation levels?
3. What is the impact of consumers' green preferences and the functional coefficient of green products on the pricing of heterogeneous substitutes and the economic benefits of supply chain members?
4. Which CSR implementation model is most conducive to improving the environmental friendliness of green products and social welfare?

To answer the above questions, the authors use game theory to construct three different model scenarios: a scenario without CSR implementation (Model N), a scenario where the retailer implements CSR (Model R), and a scenario where the manufacturer implements CSR (Model M). Through these models, the paper analyzes the impact of factors such as consumer green preferences, CSR implementation levels, and the functional coefficient of green products on supply chain decisions and performance, and compares the optimal decisions, consumer surplus, and social welfare under different CSR implementation scenarios.

In summary, this paper aims to identify the optimal CSR implementation model to promote the overall sustainable development of the supply chain by comparing the impact of different CSR implementers (manufacturers or retailers) on green and regular products within the supply chain.