Orthopaedic surgery as seen by artists and by surgeons: science or art?
Philippe Hernigou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00264-023-05771-4
IF: 3.479
2023-03-17
International Orthopaedics
Abstract:PurposeArtists, including painters, are interested in capturing the essence of the world around them, including surgery. Therefore, we explored the world of orthopaedic surgery through the eyes of artists. We asked how artists and painters have captured the artistic vision of orthopaedic surgery by describing the operation, tools and techniques used, and the patients and surgeons involved.MethodsThe evolution of medical science and the importance of an orthopaedic surgeon art in society during different centuries were evaluated from ancient civilizations to the modern world. The symbolic representation of orthopaedic surgery and orthopaedic surgeons was analyzed over time, to reflect changes in medical practice and societal attitudes towards orthopaedic surgery.ResultsAncient Egypt is where the first instances of painting a shoulder dislocation reduction were discovered. The first report of organized surgical care is found in Homer’s epic poem “Iliad,” even if executing surgical operations and artistic representation was undoubtedly done in many ancient civilizations. Orthopaedic surgeons according to the period were represented as gods, saints, monks, heroic figures, military surgeons, and sometimes politics. However, the orthopaedic surgeon was rarely considered an artist by those who are real artists. Paintings often showed orthopedists in action, with blood and tools, emphasizing the gritty reality of the surgical profession, sometimes with some stereotypes (gargantuan figure, gorilla). However, the common thread is the recognition of the skill, knowledge, and dedication required to be a surgeon and the importance of their work in helping people live healthier and more active lives.ConclusionOverall, painters have depicted orthopedic surgeons as skilled professionals who are dedicated to helping their patients achieve better health and mobility. Their depictions have evolved over time, reflecting changes in medical practice and the wider culture. However, the essential message remains the same: orthopaedic surgeons play a vital role in helping people live healthier, more active lives.
orthopedics