Abstract:DEAR EDITOR: We read with great interest the article by Rhu et al recently published in Transplantation. The authors proposed a method to classify hepatic artery reconstruction in living donor liver transplantation (LDLT) into extraanatomical reconstruction (EAR) and AR according to anatomical path and found that EAR was an alternative to AR and would not be a risk factor for biliary stricture, graft failure, and overall survival. However, we have reservations about this classification. Successful revascularization of LDLT with suboptimal options such as right gastroepiploic artery (RGEA) or jejunal artery has been described separately in previously published articles. Rhu et al categorized the use of RGEA, jejunal artery, gastroduodenal artery (GDA), and interposition graft from aorta as the EAR. However, GDA and RGEA have anatomical continuity, while jejunal artery and interposition graft from aorta have completely different starting positions, diameters, and hemodynamics. They are independent of each other and have their own pros and cons. Therefore, roughly arranging them into a group for analyses may lead to bias in research results. As an alternative, it has been mentioned that the so-called EAR group (80% RGEA) does not act as well as the AR group because surgeons were often forced to perform suboptimal anastomoses, making the conclusions of the study less innovative. To the best of our knowledge, adequate biliary blood supply is essential for the reduction of biliary complications in patients undergoing LDLT. Blood supplies to the supraduodenal bile duct (chiefly from the GDA) and even the upper bile ducts (chiefly from the left hepatic artery, middle hepatic artery, right hepatic artery, and proper hepatic artery) of LDLT are particularly important since the bile duct of the graft is relatively short and the recipient often needs to leave a longer bile duct. Therefore, we should pay more attention to the advantages and disadvantages of arteries that supply the biliary tract, namely GDA, left hepatic artery, middle hepatic artery, right hepatic artery, and proper hepatic artery, rather than RGEA and other alternatives in revascularization of LDLT. Besides, some issues regarding the study by Rhu et al come to mind. The team mentioned that the adjustment to the differences in background parameters between EAR and AR groups were appropriately made in the analyses. However, the author did not use any other methods other than the multivariate Cox proportional hazard model. We recommend the use of propensity score matching to eliminate disparities between the groups to obtain more accurate results. Perfusion and preservation with University of Wisconsin solution results in a higher incidence of biliary complications in the graft compared with histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution. However, the authors did not mention whether University of Wisconsin or histidinetryptophan-ketoglutarate solution was used. In all, this study by Rhu et al still requires further improvement and expansion.

Biliary atresia - a new derivative method?

Advanced Therapies for Congenital Biliary Tract Malformation: from Bench to Bedside

[Preliminary Experimental Study on Treatment of Portal Hypertension with Auxiliary Partial Orthotopic Liver Transplantation].

Anatomical biliary reconstruction as an ultimum refugium for selective cases—History and current state of knowledge

Pitfalls and promises of bile duct alternatives: There is plenty of room in the regenerative surgery

Biliary Atresia: Clinical and Research Challenges for the Twenty-First Century

Advanced hepatic vasculobiliary imaging segmentation and 3D reconstruction as an aid in the surgical management of high biliary stenosis

Outcomes in Children with Biliary Atresia Following Liver Transplantation.

Human Liver Organoids to Predict the Outcome of Kasai Portoenterostomy

Invited Review Journal of Pediatric Surgery Primary Liver Transplant in Biliary Atresia: The Case for and Against

Kasai Portoenterostomy, Successful Liver Transplantation, and Immunosuppressive Therapy for Biliary Atresia in a Female Baby: A Case Report

[Biliary and Gastrointestinal Bypass: Laparoscopic Possibilities].

Biliodigestive anastomosis in liver transplantation: review of 13 years

Anatomical and Extra-Anatomical Hepatic Artery Reconstruction During Living Donor Liver Transplantation: is It Reasonable to Classify This Way?

Molecular signature of active fibrogenesis prevails in biliary atresia after successful portoenterostomy

A Rescue Surgery

Bile acid profiles in adult patients with biliary atresia who achieve native liver survival after portoenterostomy

Observational Study of Biliary Duct stenosis in patients with Post-Liver Transplant

The Preliminary Study on Procurement Biliary Convergence from Donors with Complicated Bile Duct Variant in Emergency Right Lobe Living Donor Liver Transplantation

Insight into Bile Duct Reaction to Obstruction from a Three-dimensional Perspective Using ex Vivo Phase-Contrast CT

Common Clinical Problems During Treatment of Neonatal Biliary Atresia