Clinical and prognostic value of stress echocardiography appropriateness criteria for evaluation of coronary artery disease in a tertiary referral centre

Sanjeev Bhattacharyya,Vasilis Kamperidis,Navtej Chahal,Benoy N Shah,Isabelle Roussin,Wei Li,Rajdeep Khattar,Roxy Senior
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/heartjnl-2013-304949
IF: 5.7
Heart
Abstract:Objective: Appropriateness criteria for stress echocardiography (SE) have been published to reduce the rate of inappropriate testing. We sought to investigate the clinical impact and prognostic value of these criteria. Methods: 250 consecutive patients undergoing SE for evaluation of coronary artery disease were classified into appropriate, uncertain and inappropriate categories according to appropriateness criteria. A positive SE was defined as the development of new wall motion abnormalities or a biphasic response. The primary end point was the composite of myocardial infarction and death. Results: Of the 250 SE, 120 (48%) were dobutamine studies and 130 (52%) were exercise studies. 156 (62.4%), 71 (28.4%) and 23 (9.2%) were classified as appropriate, inappropriate and uncertain, respectively. A significantly greater proportion of studies classified as appropriate 71 (45.5%) demonstrated inducible ischaemia compared with inappropriate studies 9 (12.7%) or uncertain studies 4 (17.4%), p<0.0001. During a median follow-up of 12.4 months, events occurred in 18 (11.5%), 2 (2.8%) and 0 patients classified as appropriate, inappropriate and uncertain, respectively. Event-free survival was significantly reduced in patients with a SE demonstrating ischaemia compared with patients without inducible ischaemia, p<0.0001. Kaplan-Meier curves demonstrated reduced event-free survival in patients with whose studies were classified as appropriate compared to inappropriate (p=0.01) or uncertain (p=0.05). Conclusions: Appropriateness criteria differentiate between patients at high risk of ischaemia, subsequent revascularisation/cardiac events (appropriate group) and those at low risk of events (inappropriate group). A large proportion of SE is currently performed in inappropriate patients. Implementation of the criteria in clinical practice would reduce unnecessary testing.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?