Abstract:The rapid development of advanced urban air mobility, particularly electric vertical take-off and landing (eVTOL) aircraft, requires interdisciplinary approaches involving the future urban air mobility ecosystem. Operational cost efficiency, regulatory aspects, sustainability, and environmental compatibility must be incorporated directly into the preliminary design of aircraft and across operational and regulatory strategies. In this work, we present a novel multidisciplinary design optimization framework for the preliminary design of eVTOL aircraft. The framework optimizes conventional design elements of eVTOL aircraft over a generic mission and integrates a comprehensive operational cost model to directly capture economic incentives of the designed system through profit modeling for operators. We compare the optimized eVTOL system with various competing road, rail, and air transportation modes in terms of sustainability, cost, and travel time. We investigate four objective-specific eVTOL optimization designs in a broad scenario space, mapping regulatory, technical, and operational constraints to generate a representation of potential urban air mobility ecosystem conditions. The analysis of an optimized profit-maximizing eVTOL, cost-minimizing eVTOL, sustainability-maximizing eVTOL, and a combined figure of merit maximizing eVTOL design highlights significant trade-offs in the area of profitability, operational flexibility, and sustainability strategies. This underlines the importance of incorporating multiple operationally tangential disciplines into the design process.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to balance the design objectives of electric vertical take - off and landing aircraft (eVTOL) through the multidisciplinary design optimization (MDO) framework to achieve economic feasibility, ecological sustainability, short travel time and low operating costs. Specifically, the researchers proposed a brand - new multidisciplinary design optimization framework for the preliminary design of eVTOL and compared it with various competing land, rail and air transport modes in terms of sustainability, cost and travel time.
### Core problems of the paper
1. **Economic feasibility**: How to directly incorporate the operating cost model in the design stage and capture the economic benefits of the system through profit modeling?
2. **Ecological sustainability**: How to minimize the global warming potential (GWP) and ensure the least environmental impact of battery use?
3. **Travel time and operating cost**: How to optimize flight time and operating cost while meeting regulatory and technical constraints?
4. **Inter - disciplinary integration**: How to integrate economic, environmental and technical criteria into a multidisciplinary design optimization framework to generate specific eVTOL design solutions?
### Research background
With the development of urban air mobility (UAM), especially the rapid progress of eVTOL aircraft, an interdisciplinary approach is required to address the challenges in the future UAM ecosystem. Traditional research mainly focuses on optimizing aerodynamic performance, structural properties and mission efficiency, but there are still deficiencies in economic feasibility and environmental impact. Therefore, this paper aims to fill these gaps and provide a comprehensive MDO framework to guide the design and operation strategies of eVTOL.
### Methodology
The researchers adopted the genetic algorithm (GA) to solve multi - objective, multidisciplinary design optimization problems. GA can handle complex, multimodal and non - smooth objective functions and can optimize multiple conflicting objectives simultaneously. By maintaining a diverse population and fitness - based selection, the algorithm identifies a set of non - dominated solutions, forming the Pareto front, which represents the optimal trade - offs between various objectives.
### Optimization objectives
- **Minimize global warming potential (GWP)**: Consider electricity production and battery life - cycle emissions.
- **Minimize total operating cost (TOC)**: Including cash operating cost (COC), cost of ownership (COO) and indirect operating cost (IOC).
- **Maximize profit**: Based on revenue calculation of a fixed fee per kilometer.
- **Optimize the figure of merit (FoM) for transport performance**: Conduct a comprehensive assessment by combining time, carbon dioxide equivalent emissions and cost per seat - kilometer.
### Results analysis
By analyzing the design space in different scenarios, the researchers explored the eVTOL design trade - offs under specific optimization objectives. For example, in the case of minimizing TOC, select the design that can achieve the lowest TOC within the feasible region; similarly, for other objectives, corresponding decision - analysis was also carried out. Finally, the research results show the key trade - off points of eVTOL design in different scenarios, providing strategic advice for UAM stakeholders.
### Main findings
- **Significant trade - off relationships**: There are important trade - off relationships among maximizing profit, minimizing cost, reducing global warming potential and optimizing FoM.
- **Economic and environmental limitations**: Although cost - cutting and GWP - optimized designs can significantly reduce operating costs and battery costs, the extended charging time and reduced flight cycles limit their economic feasibility.
- **New evaluation criteria**: A cross - modal figure of merit (FoM) was introduced to compare the time, cost and emissions of eVTOL with other transport modes and evaluate its competitiveness.
### Conclusion
This study emphasizes the importance of integrating multiple operation - related disciplines in the eVTOL design process and proposes some key strategic suggestions, such as adopting a slow - charging protocol to maximize battery life and adapting to infrastructure with a longer wingspan to coordinate sustainability, operational efficiency and cost - effectiveness.