Robust Heart Rate Detection via Multi-Site Photoplethysmography

Manuel Meier,Christian Holz
2024-12-23
Abstract:Smartwatches have become popular for monitoring physiological parameters outside clinical settings. Using reflective photoplethysmography (PPG) sensors, such watches can non-invasively estimate heart rate (HR) in everyday environments and throughout a patient's day. However, achieving consistently high accuracy remains challenging, particularly during moments of increased motion or due to varying device placement. In this paper, we introduce a novel sensor fusion method for estimating HR that flexibly combines samples from multiple PPG sensors placed across the patient's body, including wrist, ankle, head, and sternum (chest). Our method first estimates signal quality across all inputs to dynamically integrate them into a joint and robust PPG signal for HR estimation. We evaluate our method on a novel dataset of PPG and ECG recordings from 14 participants who engaged in real-world activities outside the laboratory over the course of a whole day. Our method achieves a mean HR error of 2.4\,bpm, which is 46\% lower than the mean error of the best-performing single device (4.4\,bpm, head).
Signal Processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to achieve more accurate and stable heart rate (HR) detection through multi - site photoplethysmography (PPG) sensors in daily environments, especially when in motion or when the device - wearing position changes. Although wearable devices such as smart watches have been widely used to monitor physiological parameters, it remains challenging to maintain high - precision heart rate estimation during high - intensity exercise or in different wearing positions. ### Specific background of the problem: 1. **Existing challenges**: - **Motion artifacts**: During exercise, PPG signals are easily affected by motion artifacts, resulting in inaccurate heart rate estimation. - **Differences in device - wearing positions**: Sensors at different wearing positions (such as wrists, ankles, heads, and sternums) will generate different degrees of signal interference due to different movement patterns. 2. **Limitations of existing solutions**: - The single - sensor method is difficult to maintain high precision in complex environments. - Although existing multi - sensor fusion methods have improved, they still do not fully utilize the advantages of sensors at different sites. ### Solutions proposed in the paper: The author proposes a new multi - site PPG signal fusion method, aiming to improve the accuracy of heart rate estimation by dynamically combining signals from multiple PPG sensors. Specifically: - **Multi - site sensor combination**: Utilize PPG sensors distributed at different parts of the body (such as wrists, ankles, heads, and sternums). - **Signal quality assessment**: Conduct real - time assessment of the signal quality of each sensor to determine which signal segments can be reliably fused. - **Dynamic fusion**: Dynamically adjust the weights of the signals of each sensor according to the signal quality to generate a robust integrated PPG signal for heart rate estimation. ### Experimental verification: To verify the effectiveness of this method, the author collected a PPG and ECG data set of 14 participants during outdoor activities and conducted detailed comparative experiments. The results show that compared with the single best sensor, this method can significantly reduce the heart rate estimation error, especially in cases of high - intensity exercise. ### Main contributions: - Propose a novel multi - site PPG signal fusion method that can provide more accurate heart rate estimation in complex environments. - Verify the effectiveness and robustness of this method in practical applications, providing new ideas for the future research and development of distributed wearable health monitoring systems. Through this method, researchers hope to further improve the reliability and accuracy of wearable devices in monitoring physiological parameters in daily life, thereby better supporting personal health management.