Abstract:Probabilities of causation (PoC) offer valuable insights for informed decision-making. This paper introduces novel variants of PoC-controlled direct, natural direct, and natural indirect probability of necessity and sufficiency (PNS). These metrics quantify the necessity and sufficiency of a treatment for producing an outcome, accounting for different causal pathways. We develop identification theorems for these new PoC measures, allowing for their estimation from observational data. We demonstrate the practical application of our results through an analysis of a real-world psychology dataset.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is to quantify the necessity and sufficiency of treatment for outcomes under different causal paths by introducing new causal effect measures - the probability necessity and sufficiency of controlling direct, natural direct, and natural indirect (CD - PNS, ND - PNS, and NI - PNS). Specifically, the paper aims to answer the following three causal questions:
1. **If the mediator variable is fixed at a certain value, is the treatment still necessary and sufficient?**
2. **If there is no influence through the mediator variable, is the treatment still necessary and sufficient?**
3. **If the influence exists only through the mediator variable, is the treatment still necessary and sufficient?**
To achieve this goal, the authors developed identification theorems for these new measures and showed how to estimate these measures from observational data. In addition, the paper also demonstrated the practical application value of these methods through an application example of a real - life psychology data set.
### Specific Problem Description
- **Background**: Probabilities of Causation (PoC) are important tools for measuring whether one event is the real cause of another event. Traditional PoC include probability necessity (PN), probability sufficiency (PS), and probability necessity and sufficiency (PNS). However, existing PoC measures do not fully consider the influence of different causal paths.
- **Research Motivation**: In order to more comprehensively understand causal relationships, especially when there are mediator variables, new measures need to be introduced to quantify the necessity and sufficiency of treatment for outcomes through different paths. This not only helps in decision - making but also in explaining AI - based decision - making systems.
- **Solution**:
- **Introducing New Measures**: Define the probability necessity and sufficiency of controlling direct, natural direct, and natural indirect (CD - PNS, ND - PNS, and NI - PNS) to answer the above three causal questions.
- **Identification Theorems**: Provide identification theorems for these new measures to ensure that these measures can be estimated from observational data.
- **Practical Application**: Demonstrate the practical application effects of these new measures by analyzing a real - life psychology data set.
### Mathematical Formulas
The mathematical formulas involved in the paper are as follows:
- **Total Probability Necessity and Sufficiency (T - PNS)**:
\[
T - PNS(y; x', x, c)=P(Y_{x'} \prec y \preceq Y_x \mid C = c)
\]
- **Controlled Direct Probability Necessity and Sufficiency (CD - PNS)**:
\[
CD - PNS(y; x', x, m, c)=P(Y_{x',m} \prec y \preceq Y_{x,m} \mid C = c)
\]
- **Natural Direct Probability Necessity and Sufficiency (ND - PNS)**:
\[
ND - PNS(y; x', x, c)=P(Y_{x'} \prec y \preceq Y_x, Y_{x',M_x} \prec y \mid C = c)
\]
- **Natural Indirect Probability Necessity and Sufficiency (NI - PNS)**:
\[
NI - PNS(y; x', x, c)=P(Y_{x'} \prec y \preceq Y_x, y \preceq Y_{x',M_x} \mid C = c)
\]
These formulas respectively quantify the necessity and sufficiency of treatment in different paths through different counterfactual conditions.
### Conclusion
By introducing these new causal effect measures, the paper provides a more refined method to understand and quantify the treatment effects under different causal paths. This not only helps in decision - making but also provides strong support for explaining AI - based decision - making systems.