Accounting for Noise and Singularities in Bayesian Calibration Methods for Global 21-cm Cosmology Experiments

Christian J. Kirkham,William J. Handley,Jiacong Zhu,Kaan Artuc,Samuel A. K. Leeney,Harry T. J. Bevins,Dominic J. Anstey,Eloy de Lera Acedo
2024-12-19
Abstract:Due to the large dynamic ranges involved with separating the cosmological 21-cm signal from the Cosmic Dawn from galactic foregrounds, a well-calibrated instrument is essential to avoid biases from instrumental systematics. In this paper we present three methods for calibrating a global 21-cm cosmology experiment using the noise wave parameter formalisation to characterise a low noise amplifier including a careful consideration of how calibrator temperature noise and singularities will bias the result. The first method presented in this paper builds upon the existing conjugate priors method by weighting the calibrators by a physically motivated factor, thereby avoiding singularities and normalising the noise. The second method fits polynomials to the noise wave parameters by marginalising over the polynomial coefficients and sampling the polynomial orders as parameters. The third method introduces a physically motivated noise model to the marginalised polynomial method. Running these methods on a suite of simulated datasets based on the REACH receiver design and a lab dataset, we found that our methods produced a calibration solution which is equally as or more accurate than the existing conjugate priors method when compared with an analytic estimate of the calibrator's noise. We find in the case of the measured lab dataset the conjugate priors method is biased heavily by the large noise on the shorted load calibrator, resulting in incorrect noise wave parameter fits. This is mitigated by the methods introduced in this paper which calibrate the validation source spectra to within 5% of the noise floor.
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the problem of instrument calibration in global 21 - centimeter cosmology experiments, especially the challenges faced in separating the faint 21 - centimeter signal from the cosmic dawn and the galactic foreground. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Effects of noise and singularities**: - Since a very large dynamic range needs to be processed, it is crucial to accurately calibrate the instrument to avoid systematic errors from biasing the results. - The paper proposes three methods to calibrate global 21 - centimeter cosmology experiments, uses the noise - wave parameter formalism to characterize low - noise amplifiers, and carefully considers the calibration - temperature noise and the bias of singularities on the results. 2. **Limitations of existing methods**: - The existing conjugate - prior method has a significant bias when dealing with short - circuit load calibrators with large noise, resulting in incorrect fitting of noise - wave parameters. - The newly proposed method can calibrate the verification - source spectrum to within 5% of the noise floor by introducing a physically - motivated noise model and a polynomial - fitting method, thus solving these problems. 3. **Improving calibration accuracy**: - The paper verifies the effectiveness of the new methods through simulation data sets and laboratory data sets, proving that these methods are more accurate or at least as accurate as the existing conjugate - prior method. - Especially in the laboratory data set, the new method can better handle noise and singularity problems and improve calibration accuracy. 4. **Application of Bayesian inference**: - Use the Bayesian inference method to estimate noise - wave parameters and calibrator - noise parameters to ensure statistical robustness and accuracy. - Propose several improved Bayesian calibration methods, including Γ - weighted conjugate prior, marginalized polynomial method, and marginalized polynomial method with a noise model. In summary, this paper is committed to developing more accurate and robust calibration methods to ensure that global 21 - centimeter cosmology experiments can reliably detect the neutral - hydrogen signal in the early universe, thus providing strong support for studying the cosmic dark age, the reionization period, etc.