Clio: Privacy-Preserving Insights into Real-World AI Use

Alex Tamkin,Miles McCain,Kunal Handa,Esin Durmus,Liane Lovitt,Ankur Rathi,Saffron Huang,Alfred Mountfield,Jerry Hong,Stuart Ritchie,Michael Stern,Brian Clarke,Landon Goldberg,Theodore R. Sumers,Jared Mueller,William McEachen,Wes Mitchell,Shan Carter,Jack Clark,Jared Kaplan,Deep Ganguli
2024-12-18
Abstract:How are AI assistants being used in the real world? While model providers in theory have a window into this impact via their users' data, both privacy concerns and practical challenges have made analyzing this data difficult. To address these issues, we present Clio (Claude insights and observations), a privacy-preserving platform that uses AI assistants themselves to analyze and surface aggregated usage patterns across millions of conversations, without the need for human reviewers to read raw conversations. We validate this can be done with a high degree of accuracy and privacy by conducting extensive evaluations. We demonstrate Clio's usefulness in two broad ways. First, we share insights about how models are being used in the real world from one million <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://Claude.ai" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> Free and Pro conversations, ranging from providing advice on hairstyles to providing guidance on Git operations and concepts. We also identify the most common high-level use cases on <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://Claude.ai" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> (coding, writing, and research tasks) as well as patterns that differ across languages (e.g., conversations in Japanese discuss elder care and aging populations at higher-than-typical rates). Second, we use Clio to make our systems safer by identifying coordinated attempts to abuse our systems, monitoring for unknown unknowns during critical periods like launches of new capabilities or major world events, and improving our existing monitoring systems. We also discuss the limitations of our approach, as well as risks and ethical concerns. By enabling analysis of real-world AI usage, Clio provides a scalable platform for empirically grounded AI safety and governance.
Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence,Computation and Language,Cryptography and Security,Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to analyze and understand the actual usage of AI assistants in real - life situations while protecting user privacy. Specifically, the paper proposes a privacy - protecting platform named Clio, which aims to reveal the real - world application scenarios of AI assistants by analyzing aggregated patterns in millions of conversations without the need for manual review of the original conversation content. ### Main Problems and Background 1. **The Contradiction between Privacy Protection and Data Analysis**: - When interacting with AI assistants, users will share sensitive personal and business information, which poses a huge challenge for model providers in terms of privacy protection when analyzing these data. 2. **Ethical and Competitive Pressures**: - Manual review of conversation content may raise ethical issues, and model providers, for competitive reasons, are usually reluctant to disclose usage data, even if it is beneficial to the public interest. 3. **Excessive Data Volume**: - The amount of conversations generated daily is huge, and manual review is impractical. ### Clio's Solutions Clio solves the above problems in the following ways: - **Privacy Protection**: Clio uses multiple privacy - protection techniques (such as multi - layer privacy intervention, clustering aggregation threshold, etc.) to ensure that the final output does not contain any private user information. - **Automatic Analysis**: Utilize the AI assistant itself to conduct automatic analysis of large - scale conversation data and generate high - level usage patterns and insights. - **Interactive Exploration**: Provide an interactive interface that enables analysts to explore and understand these patterns and discover potential risks and unforeseen application scenarios. ### Application Cases 1. **Understanding Widespread Usage Patterns**: - Analyzed 1 million conversations on Claude.ai, revealing the most common high - order usage scenarios (such as programming, writing, and research tasks), and discovered significant differences between different language communities (for example, more discussions about elderly care in Japanese conversations). 2. **Improving Security Systems**: - By identifying coordinated abuse behaviors (such as automatically generating search engine optimization content, generating explicit content, etc.), monitor unknown risks and improve existing security classifiers. ### Conclusion Clio provides a scalable platform that can conduct empirical analysis of the actual usage of AI assistants while protecting user privacy, thereby providing strong support for the security and governance of AI systems.