Nods of Agreement: Webcam-Driven Avatars Improve Meeting Outcomes and Avatar Satisfaction Over Audio-Driven or Static Avatars in All-Avatar Work Videoconferencing

Fang Ma,Ju Zhang,Lev Tankelevitch,Payod Panda,Torang Asadi,Charlie Hewitt,Lohit Petikam,Marco Gillies,Xueni Pan,Sean Rintel,Marta Wilczkowiak

2024-12-18

Abstract:Avatars are edging into mainstream videoconferencing, but evaluation of how avatar animation modalities contribute to work meeting outcomes has been limited. We report a within-group videoconferencing experiment in which 68 employees of a global technology company, in 16 groups, used the same stylized avatars in three modalities (static picture, audio-animation, and webcam-animation) to complete collaborative decision-making tasks. Quantitatively, for meeting outcomes, webcam-animated avatars improved meeting effectiveness over the picture modality and were also reported to be more comfortable and inclusive than both other modalities. In terms of avatar satisfaction, there was a similar preference for webcam animation as compared to both other modalities. Our qualitative analysis shows participants expressing a preference for the holistic motion of webcam animation, and that meaningful movement outweighs realism for meeting outcomes, as evidenced through a systematic overview of ten thematic factors. We discuss implications for research and commercial deployment and conclude that webcam-animated avatars are a plausible alternative to video in work meetings.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: What are the impacts of different types of avatar animation modes on the meeting effectiveness and user satisfaction? Specifically, the author studied the performance of three different avatar animation modes (static picture, audio - driven, and webcam - driven) in work - related video conferences through experiments and evaluated their impacts on the meeting outcomes and user preferences.

### Research Background
As avatars are gradually becoming the mainstream alternative to video conferences, especially after personalized avatars were introduced on platforms such as Microsoft Teams and Zoom, how to evaluate the impacts of these avatars' animation modes on the meeting effectiveness has become an important research question. Although existing research has explored the use of avatars in social and professional environments, research on how avatar animation modes specifically affect the effectiveness of work - related meetings and user satisfaction is still limited.

### Research Questions
To fill this research gap, the author proposed two main research questions:

1. **RQ1: How do different avatar animation modes affect the meeting outcomes?**
- **Hypothesis H1a**: Meetings with webcam - animated avatars will be superior to the other two modes (static picture and audio - driven) in terms of meeting outcome factors such as effectiveness, consistency, comfort, and inclusiveness.
- **Hypothesis H1b**: Meetings with audio - animated avatars will be superior to the static picture mode in terms of meeting outcome factors.

2. **RQ2: Which avatar animation mode do users prefer?**
- **Hypothesis H2a**: Users prefer the webcam - animated avatar mode rather than the other two modes.
- **Hypothesis H2b**: Users prefer the audio - animated avatar mode rather than the static picture mode.

### Experimental Design
To answer these questions, the author conducted a mixed - method experimental study involving 68 employees from global technology companies, divided into 16 groups. Each participant used the same - style personalized avatar but used three different animation modes (static picture, audio - driven, and webcam - driven) in three tasks respectively. Through quantitative and qualitative methods, the author evaluated the impact of each mode on the meeting outcomes and user satisfaction.

### Main Findings
- **Quantitative Results**: Webcam - driven avatars significantly improved the effectiveness of the meeting and the comfort and inclusiveness of the participants, compared to static picture and audio - driven avatars.
- **Qualitative Feedback**: Participants generally believed that webcam - driven avatars provided more natural head and facial movements, which could enhance the meeting experience more than lip - syncing relying solely on sound or static pictures.
- **Thematic Analysis**: Through a systematic thematic analysis of user feedback, the author summarized ten key factors, which revealed the impact of avatar animation modes on meeting outcomes and user preferences.

### Conclusions and Significance
This study shows that webcam - driven avatars are a viable alternative in work - related video conferences, although there are some minor differences. The study also emphasizes that motion fidelity is more important than visual fidelity, which has important guiding significance for future avatar design and commercial applications.