Emergence of Power-Law and Other Wealth Distributions in Crowd of Heterogeneous Agents

Jake J. Xia

2024-12-17

Abstract:This study investigates the emergence of power-law and other concentrated distributions through a feedback loop model in crowd interactions. Agents act by their response functions to observations and external forces, while observations change by the aggregated actions of all agents, weighted by their respective influence, i.e. power or wealth. Agents wealth dynamically adjust based on the alignment between an agents actions and observation outcomes: agents gain wealth when their actions align with observed trends and lose wealth otherwise. A reward function, that describes the change of agents wealth at each time step, manifests the differences of response functions of agents to observations. When all agents responses are set to zero and feedback loop is broken, agents wealth follow a normal or lognormal distribution. Otherwise, this response-reward iterative feedback mechanism results in concentrated wealth distributions, characterized by a small number of dominant agents and the marginalization of the majority. Contrasted to past studies, such concentration is not limited only to asymptotic behavior at the upper tail for large variables, nor does it require the reward function to be linear to agents previous wealth as formulated in random growth model and network preferential attachment. Probability density functions for various distributions are more visually distinguishable for small values at the lower tail. In application of this model, key differences in income and wealth distributions in the US vs Japan are attributed to different response functions of agents in the two countries. The model applicability extends beyond social systems to other many-body systems with analogous feedback mechanisms, where power-law distributions represent a rare subset of general concentrated outcomes.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how power - law distributions and other concentrated distributions emerge through feedback - loop mechanisms in multi - agent interactions. Specifically, the author focuses on:

1. **The relationship between agent behavior and wealth change**: Research agents adjust their behavior according to observation results and external forces, and how these behaviors affect the wealth change of agents.
2. **The influence of feedback - loop mechanisms**: By introducing a feedback - loop model, study how the behavior of agents is comprehensively influenced by observation results and the behavior of other agents, and how this interaction leads to a concentrated distribution of wealth.
3. **The role of different response functions**: Analyze how different response functions of different agents to observation results affect the wealth distribution of the entire system, especially how they lead to the phenomenon that a small number of agents possess a large amount of wealth while the majority of agents have less wealth.

### Specific problem description

- **Formation mechanism of power - law distribution**: Researchers attempt to explain why power - law distributions occur in some systems instead of the common normal distribution or log - normal distribution. A notable feature of the power - law distribution is the existence of a small number of "super - agents" that possess most of the resources or wealth, while most agents are at a lower level.

- **The role of feedback - loop mechanisms**: The paper proposes a feedback - loop model in which the behavior of agents affects the observation results, and the new observation results in turn affect the behavior of agents. This dynamic process leads to a concentrated distribution of wealth.

- **The influence of different response functions**: The author pays special attention to the differences in income and wealth distributions in different countries (such as the United States and Japan), and believes that these differences can be attributed to different response functions of agents to observation results. For example, in the financial market, some investors may be momentum followers, while others may be contrarians.

### Mathematical model

To describe this process more precisely, the paper introduces the following mathematical formula to represent the behavior change of agents:

\[ dS_i = C_i \, dE + B_i \, dO + \varepsilon_i \tag{1} \]

where:
- \( dS_i \) represents the decision - making increment of the \( i \) - th agent within a certain time step;
- \( C_i \) is the response coefficient of the agent to the change in external force \( dE \);
- \( B_i \) is the response coefficient of the agent to the change in observation result \( dO \);
- \( \varepsilon_i \) is the random noise term, including the Wiener process and the drift term.

The simplified formula is:

\[ dS_i = C_i \, dE + B_i \, dO \tag{2} \]

In addition, the ability of agents to influence results is represented by \( A_i \), and this value may vary among different agents and within different time steps. The change in agent wealth is determined by a reward function that describes how agent wealth changes over time.

### Summary

The core problem of this paper is to explore how power - law distributions and other concentrated distributions are formed in multi - agent interactions by introducing a feedback - loop model and different response functions. This not only helps to understand the wealth distribution phenomenon in socio - economic systems, but can also be applied to other complex systems with similar feedback mechanisms.