Abstract:Symmetry breaking phase transitions from less to more ordered phases will typically produce topological defects in the ordered phase. Kibble-Zurek theory predicts that for any second-order phase transition, such as the early universe, the density of defects that form should be determined by the scaling law for the system coherence time and the phase transition quench time. We have performed measurements of fourth sound dissipation due to vortex mutual friction in thin channels of superfluid $^3$He where one spatial dimension is smaller than a characteristic length scale predicted by the Kibble-Zurek theory. Our measurements suggest that remnant vortices form after the normal to superfluid second-order phase transition, and that the density of vortices is correlated with the size of the channel, but crucially, is independent of quench time. We propose a modified picture of defect formation, where closely spaced walls prevent the ends of vortex lines from reconnecting into loops. This leads to a mean vortex separation set by the wall spacing, which can result in much higher defect densities than in bulk systems.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the formation density of topological defects (such as vortices) during the second - order phase transition process from the normal state to the superfluid state of superfluid $^3\text{He}$ in a confined space. Specifically, by measuring the four - phonon dissipation of superfluid $^3\text{He}$ in a confined channel, the researchers explored the relationship between the vortex density and the channel size, and found that the vortex density is independent of the quenching time but closely related to the channel size. ### Main problems 1. **Formation mechanism of topological defects (vortices)**: - The researchers are concerned with how topological defects (such as vortices) are formed during the second - order phase transition from the normal state to the superfluid state. - The Kibble - Zurek theory predicts that for any second - order phase transition, the density of defects should be determined by the scaling law of the coherence time and the phase - transition quenching time of the system. 2. **Relationship between vortex density and channel size**: - Through experimental measurements in this study, it was found that the vortex density is closely related to the channel size, rather than depending on the quenching time as predicted by the Kibble - Zurek theory. - This indicates that in a confined system, the wall spacing restricts the re - connection of the endpoints of the vortex lines, causing the average distance between the vortex lines to be determined by the wall spacing, thus forming a higher defect density. ### Experimental design and results - **Experimental device**: The researchers used a nanofluidic device (Helmholtz resonator) to confine helium gas in channels with different thicknesses (636 nm, 805 nm, 1067 nm). - **Measurement method**: By driving the superfluid Helmholtz mode, the center frequency and line width were extracted, and then the dissipation caused by the vortex mutual friction was analyzed. - **Key findings**: - The vortex density is inversely proportional to the channel thickness. The narrowest channel (636 nm) has the highest vortex density, and the widest channel (1067 nm) has the lowest vortex density. - The vortex density is independent of the quenching time, which is inconsistent with the prediction of the Kibble - Zurek theory. ### Modified model To explain this phenomenon, the researchers proposed a modified Kibble - Zurek model: - In a confined system, when the domain walls propagate outward, they will reach the walls of the device before reaching the freezing time. - If a defect is formed at the junction of the domains, it may terminate on the wall instead of forming a closed loop. This terminated vortex line cannot be infinitely shrunk to self - annihilation, so it is topologically protected. - Therefore, the relevant length scale in the confined system is not the freezing length $\hat{\xi}_{\text{KZM}}$ in the Kibble - Zurek theory, but the effective "truncated" length scale $\hat{\xi} = 2H$ set by the wall spacing. - The defect density is estimated as $L=(8H^2)^{-1}$, which is consistent with the experimental results. ### Conclusion The research results show that in the confined superfluid $^3\text{He}$, the vortex density is mainly determined by the channel size rather than the quenching time. This finding is of great significance for understanding the phase - transition dynamics in confined systems and may be applicable to the research of other similar systems.

Topologically-Protected Remnant Vortices in Confined Superfluid $^3$He

Vortex Dynamics in High-Tc Superconductors with Sparse Weak Columnar Defects

Kibble-Zurek Dynamics & Statistics of Topological Defects in Chiral Superfluid $^3$He Films

Topological defects as relics of spontaneous symmetry breaking from black hole physics

Kibble-Zurek Mechanism and Beyond: Lessons from a Holographic Superfluid Disk

Observation of vortices in a dipolar supersolid

Transverse Quantum Superfluids

Thermodynamics of random walking vortex loops in counterflowing superfluids

Quantized Vortices in Superfluids and Superconductors

Unvortex Lattice and Topological Defects in Rigidly Rotating Multicomponent Superfluids

Symmetry Protected Topological Superfluids and Superconductors --- From the Basics to $^3$He ---

Observation of universal Kibble-Zurek scaling in an atomic Fermi superfluid

Triangular pair density wave in confined superfluid $^3$He

Suppression of the superfluid Kelvin-Helmholtz instability due to massive vortex cores, friction and confinement

Vortices and Other Topological Solitons in Dense Quark Matter

Spontaneous vortices in the formation of fermionic superfluid

Competition of vortex core structures in superfluid $^3$He-B

Imaging the decay of quantized vortex rings to decipher quantum dissipation

Vortices with Fractional Flux Quanta in Multi-Band Superconductors

Connecting shear flow and vortex array instabilities in annular atomic superfluids