Open-Loop and Model Predictive Control for Electric Vehicle Charging to Manage Excess Renewable Energy Supply in Texas

Kelsey M. Nelson,Maureen S. Golan,Matthew D. Bartos,Javad Mohammadi
2024-12-12
Abstract:Modern power grids are evolving to become more interconnected, include more electric vehicles (EVs), and utilize more renewable energy sources (RES). Increased interconnectivity provides an opportunity to manage EVs and RES by using price signaling to shift EV loads towards periods of high RES output. This work uses ERCOT's 2035 RES installation plans and projections for Texas's EV fleet to examine and compare how both open-loop control and model predictive control (MPC) schemes can leverage time varying rates for EV charging to utilize excess RES supply that may otherwise be underutilized in a highly weather-dependent grid. The results show that while open-loop control increases RES usage, MPC increases RES usage even further by responding to RES outputs that differ from forecasts due to the inherent uncertainty of weather predictions. If MPC is used with time steps that are too frequent, however, difficulties arise; EV owners may find it too onerous to keep up with changing price structures, and frequent over-corrections to charging profiles can lead to a ``rebound peak" phenomenon. Therefore, control schemes should balance maximizing RES usage with ensuring customer participation.
Systems and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the problem of how to effectively utilize the excess renewable energy supply through optimizing electric vehicle (EV) charging. Specifically, the research focuses on: 1. **Reducing the waste of renewable energy sources (RES)**: With the increase in the installed capacity of renewable energy in Texas, especially in wind and solar energy, an oversupply of RES is expected. If not managed, this excess energy may be wasted (i.e., "curtailment"). Therefore, this paper explores how to maximize the utilization rate of RES through intelligent control of electric vehicle charging. 2. **Dealing with the uncertainty of weather - dependence**: The output of RES is highly dependent on weather conditions and has great volatility. The traditional fixed electricity price strategy cannot flexibly respond to this volatility and may lead to low RES utilization. For this reason, the article proposes two control schemes - open - loop control and model predictive control (MPC) - to adapt to the changes in RES output. 3. **Balancing user participation and RES utilization**: Although frequent price signal updates can improve RES utilization, they may also cause inconvenience to users and even lead to the "rebound peak" phenomenon (i.e., a new electricity consumption peak appears after frequently adjusting the charging behavior). Therefore, the research also explores how to ensure user participation and satisfaction while improving RES utilization. ### Main research content - **Background and motivation**: - As the number of electric vehicles increases and the proportion of renewable energy rises, the power grid needs to manage the interaction between the two more intelligently. - The Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) plans to significantly increase the RES installed capacity in the future, which will lead to an oversupply of RES in some periods. - By introducing time - varying rates (TVR), electric vehicles can be guided to charge when RES is abundantly supplied, thereby reducing the waste of RES. - **Research methods**: - Use ERCOT's 2035 RES installation plan and electric vehicle fleet forecast data to evaluate the effects of the two control schemes. - The open - loop control formulates a one - day charging strategy based on the prediction of the previous day, while the MPC updates the price signal every 3 or 6 hours according to the latest RES prediction. - By simulating the ERCOT grid conditions in 2035, compare the impacts of different control schemes on RES utilization. - **Results and discussion**: - The results show that MPC can utilize the excess RES more effectively than open - loop control, especially when the time step is shorter (such as 3 hours). - However, too short a time step may also make it difficult for users to adapt to frequent price changes and may trigger the rebound peak phenomenon. - Therefore, the research recommends using a 6 - hour time step as a compromise, which can improve RES utilization to a certain extent without overly affecting the user experience. ### Conclusion This paper proves through case studies that although the prediction one day in advance can improve the effect of time - varying rates, model predictive control can better deal with prediction deviations and further improve RES utilization. At the same time, the research also points out that too frequent price signal updates may lead to negative effects, such as the rebound peak phenomenon. Therefore, grid operators should weigh the benefits of using more RES against the potential negative impacts of controlling charging behavior and select an appropriate time step to ensure that users can adapt and actively participate. Future research can further explore the impact of different peak - to - valley electricity price ratios on the user response rate, as well as the impact of the frequency and magnitude of RES output and prediction deviation on the performance of the pricing control scheme. In addition, the role of other types of electric vehicles (such as electric freight vehicles and electric airplanes) in the future power grid can also be considered.