ConceptSearch: Towards Efficient Program Search Using LLMs for Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC)

Kartik Singhal,Gautam Shroff
2024-12-11
Abstract:The Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC) poses a significant challenge to artificial intelligence, demanding broad generalization and few-shot learning capabilities that remain elusive for current deep learning methods, including large language models (LLMs). While LLMs excel in program synthesis, their direct application to ARC yields limited success. To address this, we introduce ConceptSearch, a novel function-search algorithm that leverages LLMs for program generation and employs a concept-based scoring method to guide the search efficiently. Unlike simplistic pixel-based metrics like Hamming distance, ConceptSearch evaluates programs on their ability to capture the underlying transformation concept reflected in the input-output examples. We explore three scoring functions: Hamming distance, a CNN-based scoring function, and an LLM-based natural language scoring function. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of ConceptSearch, achieving a significant performance improvement over direct prompting with GPT-4. Moreover, our novel concept-based scoring exhibits up to 30% greater efficiency compared to Hamming distance, measured in terms of the number of iterations required to reach the correct solution. These findings highlight the potential of LLM-driven program search when integrated with concept-based guidance for tackling challenging generalization problems like ARC.
Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the difficulties encountered by current deep - learning methods, including large - language models (LLMs), when dealing with the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC) benchmark test. ARC emphasizes broad generalization ability and few - shot learning ability, which pose challenges to existing deep - learning methods. Specifically, these methods perform poorly when directly applied to ARC tasks, especially in capturing the underlying transformation concepts reflected in input - output examples. To meet this challenge, the author introduces a new function search algorithm - ConceptSearch. ConceptSearch utilizes LLMs for program generation and adopts a concept - based scoring method to efficiently guide the search process. Unlike simple pixel - level metrics such as Hamming distance, ConceptSearch evaluates whether a program can capture the underlying transformation concepts in input - output examples. ### Main Problems 1. **Broad Generalization and Few - Shot Learning**: ARC requires models to have the ability to generalize from a small number of examples, which is difficult for existing deep - learning methods to achieve. 2. **Limitations of Directly Applying LLMs**: Although LLMs perform well in program synthesis, their effectiveness is limited when directly applied to ARC tasks. 3. **Effective Scoring Mechanisms**: Existing scoring methods (such as Hamming distance) may not accurately reflect the effectiveness of program logic, resulting in low search efficiency. ### Solutions ConceptSearch solves the above problems in the following ways: - **Program Generation**: Utilize pre - trained LLMs to generate candidate solutions. - **Concept - Based Scoring**: Introduce three scoring functions: Hamming distance, a CNN - based scoring function, and an LLM - based natural - language scoring function. These scoring functions aim to more effectively capture the underlying transformation concepts, thereby guiding the search process. - **Multimodal Feedback**: Combine information from two modalities, visual and natural language, to provide richer feedback signals and help LLMs better understand task requirements. ### Experimental Results The experimental results show that ConceptSearch significantly outperforms the method of directly prompting GPT - 4 in performance. In particular, the concept - based scoring function improves efficiency by approximately 30% compared to Hamming distance, indicating the potential of ConceptSearch in solving complex generalization problems. ### Summary The main objective of this paper is to improve the efficiency and accuracy of solving ARC tasks by introducing the ConceptSearch algorithm, using LLMs and concept - based scoring methods. This not only demonstrates the potential of LLM - driven program search in dealing with complex generalization problems but also provides new ideas for future research. If you need more detailed formulas or technical details, please let me know and I will further explain.