I See, Therefore I Do: Estimating Causal Effects for Image Treatments

Abhinav Thorat,Ravi Kolla,Niranjan Pedanekar
2024-11-28
Abstract:Causal effect estimation under observational studies is challenging due to the lack of ground truth data and treatment assignment bias. Though various methods exist in literature for addressing this problem, most of them ignore multi-dimensional treatment information by considering it as scalar, either continuous or discrete. Recently, certain works have demonstrated the utility of this rich yet complex treatment information into the estimation process, resulting in better causal effect estimation. However, these works have been demonstrated on either graphs or textual treatments. There is a notable gap in existing literature in addressing higher dimensional data such as images that has a wide variety of applications. In this work, we propose a model named NICE (Network for Image treatments Causal effect Estimation), for estimating individual causal effects when treatments are images. NICE demonstrates an effective way to use the rich multidimensional information present in image treatments that helps in obtaining improved causal effect estimates. To evaluate the performance of NICE, we propose a novel semi-synthetic data simulation framework that generates potential outcomes when images serve as treatments. Empirical results on these datasets, under various setups including the zero-shot case, demonstrate that NICE significantly outperforms existing models that incorporate treatment information for causal effect estimation.
Artificial Intelligence,Applications,Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to estimate the causal effect of image processing in observational studies. Specifically, the authors propose a new model named NICE (Network for Image treatments Causal effect Estimation) for estimating the individual treatment effect (ITE) when the treatment is an image. The following is a detailed description of this problem: ### 1. **Background and Challenges** In the field of causal inference, especially in observational studies, estimating the causal effect is a crucial but challenging problem. The main challenges include: - **Lack of Real Data**: It is impossible to obtain the real situation of treatment assignment. - **Treatment Assignment Bias**: Treatment assignment is not random, and there are potential confounding factors. - **Multidimensional Treatment Information**: Most of the existing methods ignore the multidimensional characteristics of treatment information and simplify it into a scalar form (continuous or discrete), thus losing rich information. ### 2. **Shortcomings of Existing Work** Although some work has attempted to use complex treatment information to improve causal effect estimation, this work mainly focuses on graph structures or text processing and ignores higher - dimensional data types such as images. Therefore, when processing images, how to effectively use their rich multidimensional information for causal effect estimation remains an unsolved problem. ### 3. **Core Problems of the Paper** This paper aims to fill this gap and focuses on the following problems: - How to estimate the individual treatment effect (ITE) when the image is the treatment? - How to design a model that can effectively use image - processing information to improve the accuracy of causal effect estimation? ### 4. **Specific Application Scenarios** The authors illustrate the importance of the problem through two practical application scenarios: - **Video Platform Content Recommendation**: For example, OTT platforms use thumbnails to show content to users, with the goal of personalizing thumbnails to maximize user engagement. - **E - commerce Product Display**: E - commerce platforms show product pictures from different angles and lighting conditions, with the goal of personalizing product pictures to maximize click - through rates. ### 5. **Technical Challenges** To achieve the above goals, the main technical challenges faced by the authors include: - There is a lack of existing ITE estimation datasets suitable for image processing, and new semi - synthetic datasets need to be constructed. - There is almost no ITE estimation work for image processing in the existing literature, and there is a lack of comparable baseline methods. - Observational studies in multi - treatment settings inherit the complexity of multiple treatments, increasing the problem of confounding bias. ### 6. **Solutions** To this end, the authors propose the NICE model and solve the above problems in the following ways: - **Data Generation**: A new semi - synthetic data simulation framework is designed to generate potential results, especially when the image is the treatment. - **Model Architecture**: A new neural network architecture NICE is proposed, combining the mean squared error (MSE) and the maximum mean discrepancy (MMD) loss functions to improve the accuracy of ITE estimation. - **Experimental Verification**: The superior performance of the NICE model is verified through multiple experimental settings (including zero - sample scenarios), especially under different treatment assignment bias conditions. ### Summary The core problem of this paper is to solve how to effectively estimate the individual treatment effect (ITE) when the image is the treatment, and an innovative solution is provided by introducing the NICE model.