Abstract:Software maintainability is essential for long-term success in the software industry. Despite widespread evidence of the high costs associated with poor maintainability, market pressure drives many organizations to prioritize short-term releases. This focus leads to accumulating technical debt worldwide. In this preliminary work, we propose maintainability gamification through anonymous leaderboards to encourage organizations to maintain a sustained focus on code quality. Our approach envisions benchmarking to foster motivation and urgency across companies by highlighting thresholds for leaders and laggards. To initiate this concept, we analyze a sample of over 1,000 proprietary projects using CodeHealth scores. By examining the distribution of these scores across various dimensions, we assess the feasibility of creating effective leaderboards. Findings from this study offer valuable insights for future design activities in maintainability gamification.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problem of insufficient code maintainability in the software industry. Specifically, the author focuses on how to encourage organizations to continuously pay attention to and improve code quality by introducing "gamification of maintainability", thereby reducing technical debt (TD). The following are the core problems of the paper and their solutions:
### 1. Research Background and Problem Statement
**The Impact of Technical Debt on Software Projects**:
- Technical debt is one of the main reasons for problems in long - term software projects. It will damage key quality attributes such as maintainability, security, performance efficiency, and reliability of the project.
- Although many studies have shown the negative impact of technical debt, market pressure often makes organizations give priority to short - term releases and ignore long - term code quality maintenance.
**Existing Problems**:
- Organizations do not pay enough attention to maintainability. Only 7% of organizations systematically manage technical debt.
- In practice, the repayment of technical debt is usually carried out through refactoring, rewriting, automation, and reengineering, but these methods are not widely used.
### 2. Proposed Solutions
**Gamification of Maintainability**:
- The author proposes to motivate organizations to continuously pay attention to code quality by creating anonymous leaderboards.
- This gamification mechanism aims to stimulate the sense of competition among organizations by comparing the code health status (CodeHealth scores) among different organizations, and prompt them to actively improve code quality.
- Specific measures include:
- **Benchmarking**: By comparing the leaders and laggards in the industry, help organizations clarify the direction of improvement.
- **Anonymous Leaderboards**: Avoid directly exposing the company name, protect privacy and stimulate the internal motivation for improvement at the same time.
- **Multi - dimensional Data Analysis**: Segment according to industry fields, project scales, programming languages, etc., and provide more accurate comparison benchmarks.
### 3. Research Methods
To verify the feasibility of this solution, the author conducted the following research:
- **Data Collection and Pre - processing**: Analyzed the code health status of more than 1,000 proprietary projects and used the CodeScene tool for evaluation.
- **Data Analysis and Visualization**: Showed the code health distribution in different dimensions through the probability density function (PDF), including average code health (Average CodeHealth) and hotspot code health (Hotspot CodeHealth).
### 4. Main Findings
- **Overall Distribution**: Most projects have relatively high code health scores, but there is a long - tail phenomenon of some low - score projects.
- **Industry Differences**: There are certain differences in the code health status of different industries. Especially in large - scale projects, projects in the industrial and technological fields are more likely to have files that are difficult to maintain.
- **The Influence of Project Scale and Company Scale**: As the project scale and company scale increase, the maintainability of the code generally decreases.
- **The Influence of Codebase Age**: Older codebases (legacy projects) usually have lower code health scores, and even newly - launched projects may face maintenance challenges.
### 5. Conclusions and Future Work
- **Conclusions**: Through industry benchmarking and gamification mechanisms, organizations can be effectively motivated to continuously pay attention to code maintainability and reduce technical debt.
- **Future Work**: Further explore methods such as data envelopment analysis to more comprehensively evaluate and improve code quality; develop and deploy gamified SE platforms and manage and monitor them.
### Summary
This paper aims to solve the widespread problem of insufficient code maintainability in the software industry by introducing gamification mechanisms. Through anonymous leaderboards and benchmarking, it encourages organizations to continuously improve code quality, thereby enhancing the software maintenance level of the entire industry.