Abstract:Coordinating with others is part of our everyday experience. Previous studies using sensorimotor coordination games suggest that human dyads develop coordination strategies that can be interpreted as Nash equilibria. However, if the players are uncertain about what their partner is doing, they develop coordination strategies which are robust to the actual partner’s actions. This has suggested that humans select their actions based on an explicit prediction of what the partner will be doing – a partner model – which is probabilistic by nature. However, the mechanisms underlying the development of a joint coordination over repeated trials remain unknown. Very much like sensorimotor adaptation of individuals to external perturbations (eg force fields or visual rotations), dynamical models may help to understand how joint coordination develops over repeated trials. Here we present a general computational model – based on game theory and Bayesian estimation – designed to understand the mechanisms underlying the development of a joint coordination over repeated trials. Joint tasks are modeled as quadratic games, where each participant’s task is expressed as a quadratic cost function. Each participant predicts their partner’s next move (partner model) by optimally combining predictions and sensory observations, and selects their actions through a stochastic optimization of its expected cost, given the partner model. The model parameters include perceptual uncertainty (sensory noise), partner representation (retention rate and process noise), uncertainty in action selection and its rate of decay (which can be interpreted as the action’s learning rate). The model can be used in two ways: (i) to simulate interactive behaviors, thus helping to make specific predictions in the context of a given joint action scenario; and (ii) to analyze the action time series in actual experiments, thus providing quantitative metrics that describe individual behaviors during an actual joint action. We demonstrate the model in a variety of joint action scenarios. In a sensorimotor version of the Stag Hunt game, the model predicts that different representations of the partner lead to different Nash equilibria. In a joint two via-point (2-VP) reaching task, in which the actions consist of complex trajectories, the model captures well the observed temporal evolution of performance. For this task we also estimated the model parameters from experimental observations, which provided a comprehensive characterization of individual dyad participants. Computational models of joint action may help identifying the factors preventing or facilitating the development of coordination. They can be used in clinical settings, to interpret the observed behaviors in individuals with impaired interaction capabilities. They may also provide a theoretical basis to devise artificial agents that establish forms of coordination that facilitate neuromotor recovery.

Predictive Strategies for the Control of Complex Motor Skills: Recent Insights into Individual and Joint Actions

Behavioral Motor Performance

Predictive Mechanisms Are Not Involved the Same Way during Human-Human vs. Human-Machine Interactions: A Review

Computational joint action: dynamical models to understand the development of joint coordination

Prediction, Explanation, and Control: The Use of Mental Models in Dynamic Environments

Predictive Processing in Cognitive Robotics: A Review

Skill Learning Strategy Based on Dynamic Motion Primitives for Human–Robot Cooperative Manipulation

Concurrent predictive and prospective strategies in a simple visuomotor task

A human-aware control paradigm for human-robot interactions, a simulation study

Human Motor Learning Dynamics in High-dimensional Tasks

Adaptation through prediction: multisensory active inference torque control

Planning Human-Robot Co-manipulation with Human Motor Control Objectives and Multi-component Reaching Strategies

Motor control beyond reach—how humans hit a target with a whip

Skilled motor control implies a low entropy of states but a high entropy of actions

Neuro-cognitive mechanisms of decision making in joint action: a human-robot interaction study

Modeling motor control in continuous-time Active Inference: a survey

Coordinated social interactions are supported by integrated neural representations

Learned parametrized dynamic movement primitives with shared synergies for controlling robotic and musculoskeletal systems

Robust Control in Human Reaching Movements: A Model-Free Strategy to Compensate for Unpredictable Disturbances

Comparative analysis of motor skill acquisition in a novel bimanual task: the role of mental representation and sensorimotor feedback