Abstract:In the histories formulation of quantum theory, sets of coarse-grained histories, that are called consistent, obey classical probability rules. It has been argued that these sets can describe the semi-classical behaviour of closed quantum systems. Most physical scenarios admit multiple different consistent sets and one can view each consistent set as a separate context. Using propositions from different consistent sets to make inferences leads to paradoxes such as the contrary inferences first noted by Kent [Physical Review Letters, 78(15):2874, 1997]. Proponents of the consistent histories formulation argue that one should not mix propositions coming from different consistent sets in making logical arguments, and that paradoxes such as the aforementioned contrary inferences are nothing else than the usual microscopic paradoxes of quantum contextuality as first demonstrated by Kochen and Specker theorem. In this contribution we use the consistent histories to describe a macroscopic (semi-classical) system to show that paradoxes involving contextuality (mixing different consistent sets) persist even in the semi-classical limit. This is distinctively different from the contextuality of standard quantum theory, where the contextuality paradoxes do not persist in the semi-classical limit. Specifically, we consider different consistent sets for the arrival time of a semi-classical wave packet in an infinite square well. Surprisingly, we get consistent sets that disagree on whether the motion of the semi-classical system, that started within a subregion, ever left that subregion or not. Our results point to the need for constraints, additional to the consistency condition, to recover the correct semi-classical limit in this formalism and lead to the motto `all consistent sets are equal', but `some consistent sets are more equal than others'.

Contextuality of the probability current in quantum mechanics

Tracing quantum correlations back to collective interferences

Causation does not explain contextuality

Differential Geometry of Contextuality

Unified approach to contextuality, non-locality, and temporal correlations

On the relation between quantum theory and probability

Revisiting Quantum Contextuality in an Algebraic Framework

The Relation between Wavefunction and 3D Space Implies Many Worlds with Local Beables and Probabilities

Relational causality and classical probability: Grounding quantum phenomenology in a superclassical theory

Non-locality and quasiclassical reality in Kent's formulation of relativistic quantum theory

A computational test of quantum contextuality, and even simpler proofs of quantumness

Contrary Inferences for Classical Histories within the Consistent Histories Formulation of Quantum Theory

Lorentz covariant physical Brownian motion: Classical and quantum

Quantum Measurements and Contextuality

Corrected Bell and Noncontextuality Inequalities for Realistic Experiments

Quantum Histories and Their Implications

Corrected Bell and non-contextuality inequalities for realistic experiments

Statistical signatures of quantum contextuality

A Bayesian Account of Quantum Histories

Quantum statistical mechanics from a Bohmian perspective