Abstract:Current static verification techniques support a wide range of programs. However, such techniques only support complete and detailed specifications, which places an undue burden on users. To solve this problem, prior work proposed gradual verification, which handles complete, partial, or missing specifications by soundly combining static and dynamic checking. Gradual verification has also been extended to programs that manipulate recursive, mutable data structures on the heap. Unfortunately, this extension does not reward users with decreased dynamic checking as specifications are refined. In fact, all properties are checked dynamically regardless of any static guarantees. Additionally, no full-fledged implementation of gradual verification exists so far, which prevents studying its performance and applicability in practice. We present Gradual C0, the first practicable gradual verifier for recursive heap data structures, which targets C0, a safe subset of C designed for education. Static verifiers supporting separation logic or implicit dynamic frames use symbolic execution for reasoning; so Gradual C0, which extends one such verifier, adopts symbolic execution at its core instead of the weakest liberal precondition approach used in prior work. Our approach addresses technical challenges related to symbolic execution with imprecise specifications, heap ownership, and branching in both program statements and specification formulas. We also deal with challenges related to minimizing insertion of dynamic checks and extensibility to other programming languages beyond C0. Finally, we provide the first empirical performance evaluation of a gradual verifier, and found that on average, Gradual C0 decreases run-time overhead between 11-34% compared to the fully-dynamic approach used in prior work. Further, the worst-case scenarios for performance are predictable and avoidable.

Gradual Guarantee via Step-Indexed Logical Relations in Agda

Denotational Semantics of Gradual Typing using Synthetic Guarded Domain Theory (Extended Version)

Approximate Normalization and Eager Equality Checking for Gradual Inductive Families

Graduality from Embedding-projection Pairs (Extended Version)

Approximate normalization for gradual dependent types

Parameterized Cast Calculi and Reusable Meta-theory for Gradually Typed Lambda Calculi

Quest Complete: the Holy Grail of Gradual Security

Gradual Liquid Type Inference

Gradual Exact Logic: Unifying Hoare Logic and Incorrectness Logic via Gradual Verification

Solver-based Gradual Type Migration

Logical Step-Indexed Logical Relations

Gradual Typing for Effect Handlers

Gradual Sensitivity Typing

Guard Analysis and Safe Erasure Gradual Typing: a Type System for Elixir

Type-directed operational semantics for gradual typing

Gradual C0: Symbolic Execution for Gradual Verification

Gradual Typing in an Open World

GADTs meet subtyping

Gradual Typing for Extensibility by Rows

k-Step Relative Inductive Generalization

A Theory of Changes for Higher-Order Languages - Incrementalizing λ-Calculi by Static Differentiation