Supporting Gig Worker Needs and Advancing Policy Through Worker-Centered Data-Sharing

Jane Hsieh,Angie Zhang,Mialy Rasetarinera,Erik Chou,Daniel Ngo,Karen Lightman,Min Kyung Lee,Haiyi Zhu
2024-12-04
Abstract:The proliferating adoption of platform-based gig work increasingly raises concerns for worker conditions. Past studies documented how platforms leveraged design to exploit labor, withheld information to generate power asymmetries, and left workers alone to manage logistical overheads as well as social isolation. However, researchers also called attention to the potential of helping workers overcome such costs via worker-led datasharing, which can enable collective actions and mutual aid among workers, while offering advocates, lawmakers and regulatory bodies insights for improving work conditions. To understand stakeholders' desiderata for a data-sharing system (i.e. functionality and policy initiatives that it can serve), we interviewed 11 policy domain experts in the U.S. and conducted co-design workshops with 14 active gig workers across four domains. Our results outline policymakers' prioritized initiatives, information needs, and (mis)alignments with workers' concerns and desires around data collectives. We offer design recommendations for data-sharing systems that support worker needs while bringing us closer to legislation that promote more thriving and equitable gig work futures.
Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to support the needs of gig workers through a worker - centered data - sharing system and promote the formulation and implementation of relevant policies**. Specifically, the paper aims to: 1. **Understand the priorities and needs of policy experts and gig workers in terms of data sharing**: Researchers understand the expectations and needs of both parties for the data - sharing system through interviewing policy - area experts and conducting co - design workshops with gig workers. This includes identifying which policy initiatives are jointly supported by workers and policy experts, and what are their respective unique concerns. 2. **Determine the specific types of worker data that need to be shared**: In order to promote the above - mentioned policy initiatives, researchers explore specific types of worker data, which can provide a basis for policy - making and help workers take collective action. 3. **Explore the practical challenges and preferences in implementing the data - sharing system**: Researchers also investigate the challenges that workers and policy - related parties may encounter in the actual operation of the data - sharing system and their respective preferences, such as privacy protection, trust - building, etc. ### Paper Background In recent years, with the rapid development of the platform - based gig economy, the issue of working conditions faced by gig workers has received increasing attention. Existing research has shown that platforms transfer many costs and risks to workers through algorithmic management, which damages their health, safety, financial stability and overall well - being. Therefore, scholars have called for strengthening the supervision of digital labor platforms through legislative and regulatory means. However, due to the platforms' unwillingness to share relevant data, there is a data gap among advocates, policy - makers and the public in promoting the improvement of gig working conditions. ### Research Methods To fill this gap, this study adopts a two - step approach: - **First stage: Interview policy - area experts**: Researchers conducted semi - structured interviews with 11 policy experts from different levels of government agencies to collect their policy priorities for the data - sharing system and their feedback. - **Second stage: Conduct co - design workshops with gig workers**: Subsequently, researchers organized four co - design workshops, involving 14 gig workers active in the United States, covering four different gig areas (such as freelancing, food delivery, ride - hailing and pet - sitting). Through these workshops, researchers gained in - depth understanding of workers' motives for the data - sharing system, the types of data they care about, their sharing preferences and their views on platform governance. ### Main Contributions The main contributions of this paper are: 1. Expand the community's understanding of the data required for policy initiatives and clarify the commonalities and differences between workers and policy experts. 2. Identify the similarities and differences in policy priorities between workers and policy experts, providing a basis for further cooperation. 3. Map out the practical challenges faced by worker data - sharing, providing guidance for future design of data - sharing systems. In short, this study aims to design a data - sharing system that can meet the needs of workers and promote a more fair and dynamic future of the gig economy by in - depth understanding of the needs of workers and policy experts.