Detecting Hidden Orders in frustrated magnets
Gang Chen,Yao Shen,Jun Zhao,Yaodong Li,Changle Liu,Xiaoqun Wang,Yuesheng Li,Wei Tong,Li Pi,Juanjuan Liu,Zhaorong Yang,Qingming Zhang
2019-01-01
Abstract:We report the magnetic properties of compounds in the KBaRE(BO3)2 family (RE= Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, m, Yb), materials with a planar triangular lattice composed of rare earth ions. The samples were analyzed by x-ray diffraction and crystallize in the space group R3m. Physical property measurements indicate the compounds display predominantly antiferromagnetic interactions between spins without any signs of magnetic ordering above 1.8 K. The i eal 2D rare earth triangular layers in this structure type make it a potential model system for investigating magnetic frustration in rare-earth-based materials. Figure 2 YMGO is not alone: lots f isostructural materials Many ternary chalcogenides NaRES2 , NaRESe2 , KRES2 , KRESe2 ,
KRETe2 , RbRES2 , RbRESe2 , RbRETe2 , CsRES2 , CsRESe2, etc.) C Liu, YD Li, GC*, PRB 98, 045119 (2018) Gang Chen’s theory gr up Ga g Ch n’s th ory group Model Hamiltonian for all cases CHANGLE LIU, YAO-DONG LI, AND GANG CHEN PHYSICAL REVIEW B 98, 045119 (2018) TABLE I. The relevant spin Hamiltonians for three different doublets on the triangular lattice. The models for the usual Kramers doublet and the dipole-octupole doublet have been obtained in the previous works. Local doublets The nearest-neighbor spin Hamiltonians on the triangular lattice Reference Usual Kramers doublet H = ∑ ⟨ij ⟩ JzzS z i S z j + J±(S i S− j + S− i S+ j ) + J±±(γij S+ i S+ j + γ ∗ ij S− i S− j )− iJz± 2 Refs. [3,4] [(γ ∗ ij S + i − γij S− i )S j + S i (γ ∗ ij S+ j − γij S− j )] Dipole-octupole doublet H = ∑ ⟨ij ⟩ JzS z i S z j + JxS i S j + JyS y i S y j + Jyz(S i S y j + S y i S z j ) Ref. [10] Non-Kramers doublet H = ∑ ⟨ij ⟩ JzzS z i S z j + J±(S i S− j + S− i S+ j ) + J±±(γij S+ i S+ j + γ ∗ ij S− i S− j ) This paper relevant for the spin liquid candidate YbMgGaO4 and many other rare-earth triangular lattice magnets with Kramers ion. In this paper, we turn our attention to the non-Kramers doublet on the triangular lattice that has been advocated in the end of Ref. [4], and complete the full list of the microscopic spin models for the triangular lattice rare-earth magnets. Unlike the usual Kramers doublets, the mixed multipolar natures of spin components for the non-Kramers doublets greatly simplify the spin Hamiltonian. For the non-Kramers doublets [33–35], the longitudinal spin component behaves as the magnetic dipole moment, while the transverse spin components behave as the magnetic quadrupole moment. Therefore, the timereversal symmetry and the hermiticity condition forbid the coupling between the longitudinal and the transverse components. Moreover, the ordering in the longitudinal spin components and the ordering in the transverse components have to be distinct and necessarily correspond to different phases and phase transitions. The purpose of this paper is to understand the intertwined multipolar ordering structures and the relevant experimental phenomena for the non-Kramers doublets on the triangular lattice. The magnetic dipolar order can be directly visible through the conventional magnetic measurements such as the NMR and neutron diffraction experiments. The magnetic quadrupolar order (or, equivalently, spin nematicity) preserves the timereversal symmetry and is often not quite visible in such conventional measurements. However, the dipole component that is orthogonal to the quadrupole component could then create quantum fluctuations for the quadrupole component and lead to coherent spin wave excitations. This orthogonal effect allows the detection of the spin wave spectra via the inelastic neutron scattering measurements. If the quadrupolar order breaks the translation symmetry and enlarges the unit cell, the symmetry-breaking pattern may not be quite visible in the static measurement, but is clear in the dynamic measurements. Thus, we study the magnetic excitations in the multipolar ordered phases. We establish the key connections between the underlying multipolar structure and the features in the excitation spectra. The orthogonal effect of the dipole component on the quadrupole component further lies in the coupling to the external magnetic field. The magnetic field only couples linearly to the dipole component and, thus, the magnetization and the magnetic susceptibility indirectly suggest the underlying quadrupolar order and transition. The following part of the paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we propose the relevant physical model for the nonKramers doublets on a triangular lattice and explain the physical significance of the spin operators. In Sec. III, we employ several different methods to obtain the full phase diagram of this model. Since many states have an emergentU (1) symmetry at the mean-field level, in Sec. IV, we study the quantum order by disorder phenomena for two representative states on our phase diagram. In Sec. V, we study the dynamic properties of the distinct phases that can serve as the experimental probes of the underlying multipolar orders. In Sec. VI, we point out the unique magnetization process due to the selective coupling of the moments to the external magnetic field. Finally, in Sec. VII, we discuss the experimental detection of various phases and summarize with a materials’ survey. In Appendix A, we explain the relevance of the model to the Kitaev interaction. In Appendix B, we give the explanation of the non-Kramers doublet for the case of the spin-1 moments. In Appendix C, we show the complete spin wave dispersions for different phases. II. MODEL HAMILTONIAN Apart from YbMgGaO4, RCd3P3, RZn3P3, RCd3As3, RZn3As3, KBaR(BO3)2, and many ternary chalcogenides (LiRSe2, NaRS2, NaRSe2, KRS2, KRSe2, KRTe2, RbRS2, RbRSe2, RbRTe2, CsRS2, CsRSe2, CsRTe2, etc.) are known to have the rare-earth local moments on the triangular lattices, where R is the rare-earth atom. These chemical properties of the rare-earth atoms are quite similar, and thus it is often possible to substitute one for the other. A rare-earth ion, such as Yb3+ and Sm3+, that contains odd number of electrons is the Kramers’ ion and forms a ground-state doublet whose twofold degeneracy is protected by the time-reversal symmetry and the Kramers’ theorem. A non-Kramers ion like Pr3+ and Tb3+ contains an even number of electrons per site (see Fig. 1). The spin-orbit coupling of the 4f electrons entangles the total spin moment and the orbital angular momentum, and leads to a total moment J that is an integer. The crystal electric field then splits the 2J + 1 fold degeneracy and sometimes leads to a twofold degenerate ground-state doublet. Although both Kramers doublet and non-Kramers doublet are two-dimensional irreducible representations of the point group, the twofold degeneracy of the Kramers doublets is further protected by the time-reversal symmetry, and the degeneracy of the non-Kramers doublets is merely protected by the lattice symmetry. For these nonKramers doublets, one then introduces an effective spin-1/2 operator, Si , that acts on the twofold degenerate ground-state doublet at each lattice site (see Appendix B for a more detailed discussion for a specific case.) Although the effective spin-1/2 operator is introduced to describe the non-Kramers doublet, the actual wave functions of the non-Kramers doublets are still integer spins in nature. As a result, the transformation of these effective spin-1/2 operators for the non-Kramers doublet is quite different from 045119-2 Gang Chen’s th ory group Gang Chen’s theory group Model for non-Kramers doublets SELECTIVE MEASUREMENTS OF INTERTWINED ... PHYSICAL REVIEW B 98, 045119 (2018) FIG. 2. (a) The triangular lattice with three distinct neighboring bonds and interactions. The phase parameter γij depends on the bond orientation, which reflects the spin-orbit-entangled nature of the local moments. (b) The definition of the Brillouin zone for the triangular lattice. the effective spin-1/2 operators for the Kramers doublet under the time-reversal symmetry. Specifically, the longitudinal component, S i , is odd under time reversal and transforms as a magnetic dipole moment, and the transverse components, S i and S y i , are even under time reversal and transform as the magnetic quadrupolar moment. Therefore, the generic symmetry-allowed spin Hamiltonian that describes the interaction between the non-Kramers doublets on the triangular lattice is simpler than the one for the Kramers doublets and is given as [4]