Preserving Information: How does Topological Data Analysis improve Neural Network performance?

A. Stolarek,W. Jaworek
2024-11-27
Abstract:Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) require significant amounts of data and computational resources to achieve high effectiveness in performing the tasks for which they are trained. To reduce resource demands, various techniques, such as Neuron Pruning, are applied. Due to the complex structure of ANNs, interpreting the behavior of hidden layers and the features they recognize in the data is challenging. A lack of comprehensive understanding of which information is utilized during inference can lead to inefficient use of available data, thereby lowering the overall performance of the models. In this paper, we introduce a method for integrating Topological Data Analysis (TDA) with Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) in the context of image recognition. This method significantly enhances the performance of neural networks by leveraging a broader range of information present in the data, enabling the model to make more informed and accurate predictions. Our approach, further referred to as Vector Stitching, involves combining raw image data with additional topological information derived through TDA methods. This approach enables the neural network to train on an enriched dataset, incorporating topological features that might otherwise remain unexploited or not captured by the network's inherent mechanisms. The results of our experiments highlight the potential of incorporating results of additional data analysis into the network's inference process, resulting in enhanced performance in pattern recognition tasks in digital images, particularly when using limited datasets. This work contributes to the development of methods for integrating TDA with deep learning and explores how concepts from Information Theory can explain the performance of such hybrid methods in practical implementation environments.
Neural and Evolutionary Computing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to improve the performance of neural networks in image recognition tasks by combining Topological Data Analysis (TDA) with Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN). Specifically, the paper explores how to use the extra information provided by Topological Data Analysis to enhance the neural network's understanding of complex patterns in data, thereby improving the model's prediction accuracy and robustness in cases where the amount of data is limited or the data noise is large. ### Background of the Paper - **Problem Background**: Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) require a large amount of data and computing resources to achieve high - efficiency task execution. To reduce resource requirements, researchers have applied various techniques, such as Neuron Pruning. However, due to the complexity of the neural network structure, the behavior of the hidden layers and the data features they recognize are difficult to interpret. The lack of a comprehensive understanding of this information may lead to inefficient use of data, thereby reducing the overall performance of the model. - **Research Motivation**: The paper proposes a method that combines Topological Data Analysis (TDA) with Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) for image recognition tasks. Through this method, a wider range of information in the data can be utilized, enabling the model to make more accurate predictions. ### Solutions - **Method**: The paper introduces a method called "Vector Stitching", which combines the original image data with the topological information extracted by the TDA method. In this way, the neural network can utilize these topological features during the training process, which may not be fully utilized or captured in traditional network mechanisms. - **Experimental Design**: The paper conducted experiments on the MNIST dataset and compared the performance of three different models: - **RAW model**: Trained only with the original grayscale images. - **TDA model**: Trained only with the topological features represented by Persistence Images. - **Vector Stitching model**: Trained with a combination of the original image and Persistence Images. ### Experimental Results - **Training with Clean Data**: When trained only with clean data, the Vector Stitching model achieved an accuracy rate of 70% on the smallest training set (100 images) and 82% on the largest training set (1,000 images). In contrast, the original model was unable to generalize the information extracted from clean images to classify noisy images, and although the model based on Persistence Images showed some improvement as the training set increased, it only reached an accuracy rate of about 30% at most. - **Training with Mixed Data**: On a mixed training set of 90% clean data and 10% noisy data, the Vector Stitching model still performed the best, achieving an accuracy rate of 90% on the largest training set (1,000 images). The accuracy rates of the other models were 70% (Persistence Images model) and 83% (original model), respectively. ### Conclusions - **Main Findings**: The experimental results show that by combining Topological Data Analysis with Convolutional Neural Networks, the performance of image classification tasks can be significantly improved, especially when the data is noisy. The Vector Stitching method performs well on both clean data and noisy data, verifying the potential of this method in effectively extracting data information. - **Future Directions**: The paper also discusses further research directions, including exploring how to incorporate more topological information into deep - learning models and how to use the concepts of information theory to explain the performance improvement of these hybrid methods in practical application environments. Through these studies, the paper provides a new perspective for the combination of Topological Data Analysis and deep learning, and is expected to promote further development in related fields in the future.