Understanding the Impact of Spatial Immersion in Web Data Stories

Seon Gyeom Kim,Juhyeong Park,Yutaek Song,Donggun Lee,Yubin Lee,Ryan Rossi,Jane Hoffswell,Eunyee Koh,Tak Yeon Lee

2024-11-27

Abstract:An increasing number of web articles engage the reader with the feeling of being immersed in the data space. However, the exact characteristics of spatial immersion in the context of visual storytelling remain vague. For example, what are the common design patterns of data stories with spatial immersion? How do they affect the reader's experience? To gain a deeper understanding of the subject, we collected 23 distinct data stories with spatial immersion, and identified six design patterns, such as cinematic camera shots and transitions, intuitive data representations, realism, naturally moving elements, direct manipulation of camera or visualization, and dynamic dimension. Subsequently, we designed four data stories and conducted a crowdsourced user study comparing three design variations (static, animated, and immersive). Our results suggest that data stories with the design patterns for spatial immersion are more interesting and persuasive than static or animated ones, but no single condition was deemed more understandable or trustworthy.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the impact of spatial immersion in web - based data stories. Specifically, the researchers focus on the following aspects:

1. **What are the design patterns that cause spatial immersion?**
- By collecting 23 data stories with spatial immersion, the author identified six common design patterns:
- **Cinematic camera shots and transitions**: Enhance the reader's spatial immersion through different camera angles and transitions.
- **Intuitive data representations**: Encode colors, shapes, animations, etc. in analogy with the phenomena or spaces in the narrative, making it easier for readers to understand.
- **Naturally moving elements**: Use smooth and natural element movements to attract the reader's attention and indirectly help them feel the virtual space.
- **Direct manipulation of camera or visualization**: Allow readers to freely explore the virtual space, thus directly promoting spatial immersion.
- **Realism**: Use various rendering techniques (such as image mapping, texture mapping, lighting and shadow effects) to achieve realistic visual effects.
- **Dynamic dimension**: Enhance spatial immersion by introducing additional dimensions (such as time, depth, etc.).

2. **How does spatial immersion affect the reader's experience?**
- To answer this question, the author designed four data stories and created three design variants (static, animated, immersive) for each story. Then, the impact of these variants on the reading experience was compared through crowdsourced user research.
- The research results show that data stories with spatial immersion design patterns are more interesting and more persuasive than the static or animated versions, but there are no significant differences in comprehensibility and credibility.

Through the research of these problems, the author hopes to better understand the role of spatial immersion in visual data stories and its impact on the reader's experience, so as to provide guidance for future designs.