Privacy-Preserving Behaviour of Chatbot Users: Steering Through Trust Dynamics

Julia Ive,Vishal Yadav,Mariia Ignashina,Matthew Rand,Paulina Bondaronek
2024-11-27
Abstract:Introduction: The use of chatbots is becoming increasingly important across various aspects of daily life. However, the privacy concerns associated with these communications have not yet been thoroughly addressed. The aim of this study was to investigate user awareness of privacy risks in chatbot interactions, the privacy-preserving behaviours users practice, and how these behaviours relate to their awareness of privacy threats, even when no immediate threat is perceived. Methods: We developed a novel "privacy-safe" setup to analyse user behaviour under the guarantees of anonymization and non-sharing. We employed a mixed-methods approach, starting with the quantification of broader trends by coding responses, followed by conducting a qualitative content analysis to gain deeper insights. Results: Overall, there was a substantial lack of understanding among users about how chatbot providers handle data (27% of the participants) and the basics of privacy risks (76% of the participants). Older users, in particular, expressed fears that chatbot providers might sell their data. Moreover, even users with privacy knowledge do not consistently exhibit privacy-preserving behaviours when assured of transparent data processing by chatbots. Notably, under-protective behaviours were observed among more expert users. Discussion: These findings highlight the need for a strategic approach to enhance user education on privacy concepts to ensure informed decision when interacting with chatbot technology. This includes the development of tools to help users monitor and control the information they share with chatbots
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore and analyze users' awareness of privacy risks and their privacy - protecting behaviors when interacting with chatbots. Specifically, the research mainly focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Users' awareness of privacy risks**: - Research whether users are aware of the possible privacy risks when communicating with chatbots. - Evaluate users' understanding of privacy threats, such as personal information leakage, identity recognition, etc. 2. **Users' privacy - protecting behaviors**: - Analyze the privacy - protecting measures taken by users when interacting with chatbots. - Explore the relationship between these behaviors and users' awareness of privacy threats, especially in the absence of obvious privacy threats. 3. **The privacy paradox phenomenon**: - The research finds that even if users have certain privacy knowledge, they do not always show consistent privacy - protecting behaviors in actual actions. This phenomenon is called "privacy paradox", that is, although users care about privacy, they over - share information in actual operations. ### Research background With the wide application of chatbots in daily life, such as in finance, law, public services, consumption, and medical fields, privacy issues have gradually become the focus of people's attention. Although chatbots provide convenient services, their data processing methods and potential security risks have not been fully valued. Therefore, this research hopes to provide a basis for improving users' privacy awareness and formulating more effective privacy - protecting measures by investigating users' behaviors and awareness. ### Research methods In order to answer the above questions, the researchers adopted a mixed - methods approach, including quantitative and qualitative analysis: - **Quantitative analysis**: Quantify users' information - sharing situations in different situations by coding questionnaires and chat records. - **Qualitative analysis**: Through content analysis, deeply explore users' specific behaviors and attitudes, especially those users who show the privacy paradox phenomenon. ### Main findings 1. **Insufficient awareness of privacy risks among users**: - Most users (76%) lack an understanding of basic privacy risks, especially regarding how chatbots process user data. - Elderly users are especially worried that chatbot providers may sell their data. 2. **Inconsistent privacy - protecting behaviors**: - Even users with privacy knowledge may not show consistent privacy - protecting behaviors after being informed of a transparent data - processing process. - Expert users sometimes show the behavior of over - sharing information, which may be due to their trust in technology or underestimation of risks. 3. **The privacy paradox phenomenon is widespread**: - In chatbot interactions, users tend to focus more on short - term convenience and ease of use, ignoring long - term privacy risks. ### Conclusions and suggestions The research results emphasize the importance of improving users' privacy awareness and point out that simply increasing users' knowledge may not be enough to change their behaviors. For this reason, the researchers suggest developing tools to help users monitor and control the information shared with chatbots, and providing reminder mechanisms when necessary to promote more consistent privacy - protecting behaviors. In addition, further research is needed to understand the deep - seated reasons behind the privacy paradox and explore more effective intervention measures. ### Keywords - Chatbot - Privacy - Privacy paradox - Qualitative method Through the above summary, this paper not only reveals the current privacy challenges faced by users when using chatbots, but also provides valuable references for future research and practice.