Superconductivity in WBe2

J. S. Kim,P. M. Dee,J. J. Hamlin,P. J. Hirschfeld,G. R. Stewart

2024-11-26

Abstract:WBe2, which occurs in space group 194, with hexagonal symmetry P63/mmc, is prepared by arc-melting at temperatures above 2200 C, where Be vapor loss is significant. This study is motivated by recent work on MoB2 and WB2, both superconductors (Tc=32 and 17 K respectively) under high (~70 GPa) pressure. In order to avoid the known Be-rich superconducting phases (WBe13 and WBe22) in the complex phase diagram, both known to be superconducting at 4.1 K, the sample was prepared with a slight (~5%) excess of W. The resultant sample, prepared using high purity (99.999%) Be, is essentially single phase WBe2, with some spread in its superconducting properties due to the known homogeneity range. (WBe2 forms in space group 194 between approximately W1.02Be1.98 and W0.88Be2.12.) Characterization was carried out with x-ray diffraction, electrical resistivity, rho, in zero and applied magnetic fields, and specific heat. The resistivity in zero and applied fields and specific heat data indicate that our sample of WBe2 is a bulk superconductor at ambient pressure with a Tc(onset) in the resistivity at 1.05 K, and Tc(rho->0) at ~0.86 K. There is no signature of superconductivity in rho at 4.1 K, indicating successful avoidance of WBe13 and WBe22. The resistivity data in field indicate an upper critical field of approximately 400 gauss.

Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the superconducting properties of tungsten beryllide (WBe₂) at ambient pressure. Specifically, the researchers hope to determine whether WBe₂ is superconducting and understand its superconducting transition temperature (Tc) and other related properties.

### Research Background and Motivation
1. **Known Superconducting Materials**:
- Recent research has found that MoB₂ exhibits a superconducting transition temperature of 32 K under high pressure (about 70 GPa).
- WB₂ also shows superconductivity of 17 K under high pressure (more than 50 GPa).

2. **Avoiding Known Beryllium - Rich Phases**:
- It is known that two beryllium - rich phases, WBe₁₃ and WBe₂₂, exhibit superconductivity at 4.1 K.
- In order to avoid these known superconducting phases, the researchers deliberately added about 5% excess tungsten (W) when preparing WBe₂ samples.

### Main Research Questions
- **Superconductivity of WBe₂**: Does WBe₂ exhibit superconductivity at ambient pressure?
- **Superconducting Transition Temperature (Tc)**: If WBe₂ is a superconductor, what is its superconducting transition temperature?
- **Superconducting Mechanism**: What is the superconducting mechanism of WBe₂? How is it related to the structure, the electronic density of states (N(0)), and the electron - phonon coupling parameter (λ)?

### Experimental Methods and Results
1. **Sample Preparation**:
- WBe₂ samples were prepared by arc - melting method using high - purity (99.999%) beryllium (Be) and tungsten (W).
- Due to the high vapor pressure of Be at high temperatures, an excess amount of Be was used during the preparation process to compensate for the loss.

2. **Characterization Methods**:
- **X - ray Diffraction (XRD)**: It was confirmed that the main component of the sample was WBe₂, with a small amount of unreacted W.
- **Resistivity Measurement**: The resistivity was measured in zero magnetic field and an applied magnetic field. The results showed that WBe₂ entered the superconducting state at 1.05 K, and the temperature at which it completely transformed into zero resistance was 0.86 K.
- **Specific Heat Measurement**: The superconducting transition temperature of WBe₂ was further confirmed to be about 0.88 K through specific heat measurement.

### Conclusions
- WBe₂ does exhibit superconductivity at ambient pressure, and the superconducting transition temperature is about 1 K.
- Compared with WBe₁₃ and WBe₂₂, the superconducting transition temperature of WBe₂ is lower, which may be related to its structure and electronic density of states.
- The researchers speculate that the longer W - Be bond length and the more open structure in WBe₂ lead to the lower superconducting transition temperature.

### Formula Summary
- Superconducting Transition Temperature Formula (BCS Theory):
\[
T_c \propto \exp\left(-\frac{1}{\lambda N(0)}\right)
\]
where \( T_c \) is the superconducting transition temperature, \( \lambda \) is the electron - phonon coupling parameter, and \( N(0) \) is the electronic density of states at the Fermi level.

- McMillan Formula for Estimating the Electron - phonon Coupling Parameter:
\[
\lambda = \frac{1.04}{N(0)} \quad \text{(calculated from specific heat data)}
\]

- Rowell's Superconducting Transition Temperature Model:
\[
T_c = \left(\frac{\Theta_D}{20}\right) (\lambda - 0.25)
\]
where \( \Theta_D \) is the Debye temperature.

Through these studies, the paper reveals the superconducting properties of WBe₂ at ambient pressure and provides important clues for further understanding its superconducting mechanism.