Coherence Based Sound Speed Aberration Correction -- with clinical validation in fetal ultrasound

Anders Emil Vrålstad,Peter Fosodeder,Karin Ulrike Deibele,Siri Ann Nyrnes,Ole Marius Hoel Rindal,Vibeke Skoura-Torvik,Martin Mienkina,Svein-Erik Måsøy
2024-12-06
Abstract:The purpose of this work is to demonstrate a robust and clinically validated method for correcting sound speed aberrations in medical ultrasound. We propose a correction method that calculates focusing delays directly from the observed two-way distributed average sound speed. The method beamforms multiple coherence images and selects the sound speed that maximizes the coherence for each image pixel. The main contribution of this work is the direct estimation of aberration, without the ill-posed inversion of a local sound speed map, and the proposed processing of coherence images which adapts to in vivo situations where low coherent regions and off-axis scattering represents a challenge. The method is validated in vitro and in silico showing high correlation with ground truth speed of sound maps. Further, the method is clinically validated by being applied to channel data recorded from 172 obstetric Bmode images, and 12 case examples are presented and discussed in detail. The data is recorded with a GE HealthCare Voluson Expert 22 system with an eM6c matrix array probe. The images are evaluated by three expert clinicians, and the results show that the corrected images are preferred or gave equivalent quality to no correction (1540m/s) for 72.5% of the 172 images. In addition, a sharpness metric from digital photography is used to quantify image quality improvement. The increase in sharpness and the change in average sound speed are shown to be linearly correlated with a Pearson Correlation Coefficient of 0.67.
Image and Video Processing,Medical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to present a robust and clinically - validated method for correcting the sound - speed distortion in medical ultrasound. Specifically, the author proposes a method to calculate the focusing delay directly from the observed round - trip distributed average sound speed and selects the sound speed by maximizing the coherence of each image pixel. This method avoids the ill - posed inversion of the local sound - speed map and adapts to challenges such as low - coherence areas and off - axis scattering in in - vivo situations. #### Main problems and background 1. **The influence of sound - speed deviation on the quality of ultrasound imaging**: - Sound speed is a fundamental parameter in medical ultrasound imaging and determines the focusing effect of the ultrasound system. Deviations between the actual sound speed and the assumed value will affect the image quality. - Traditional ultrasound systems usually assume a sound speed of 1,540 m/s, but in some cases (such as patients with high - fat tissues), the actual sound speed may deviate from this assumed value (for example, the sound speed of fat is 1,450 m/s). 2. **The requirements for fetal ultrasound diagnosis**: - In fetal ultrasound diagnosis, it is especially important to improve contrast and clarity. Accurate information is crucial for parental consultation and decision - making. - Early detection and diagnosis (such as fetal congenital heart disease) have an important impact on the survival rate and morbidity of newborns. 3. **The limitations of existing methods**: - Existing methods for sound - speed reconstruction and distortion correction usually need to estimate the local sound - speed map and then calculate the propagation time to focus the received signal. However, this estimation is ill - posed because there are multiple local sound - speed maps that can produce the same average sound speed. #### Main contributions of the paper - Proposes a coherence - based sound - speed distortion correction method that calculates the focusing delay directly from the average sound - speed map and avoids the ill - posed inversion of the local sound - speed map. - This method has been verified on in - vitro, simulated, and clinical data, showing a high correlation with the real sound - speed map. - Clinical verification shows that in 72.5% of cases, the corrected image is better than or equivalent to the uncorrected image (assuming a sound speed of 1,540 m/s). - Uses the sharpness index from digital photography to quantify the improvement in image quality, and the results show a linear correlation between the increase in image sharpness and the change in average sound speed, with a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.67. ### Summary This paper mainly solves the image - quality problems in medical ultrasound imaging caused by sound - speed deviation, especially for the application of fetal ultrasound diagnosis. By proposing a new coherence - based sound - speed distortion correction method, the author demonstrates its effectiveness in in - vitro, simulated, and clinical verification, significantly improving image quality and diagnostic accuracy.