Abstract:Background: In recent years, marketplaces in the darknet emerged where vendors and customers can exchange illicit drugs and other goods on digital platforms by using hidden internet services. The main thesis of this paper is that in an online environment, different practices for building trust and reputation emerge that stabilise market processes. Methods: Qualitative and quantitative data from a recent German project on conventional (offline) small-scale drug dealing as well as qualitative case studies on four online vendors operating on Agora market are used to explore alternative practices for building trust and reputation. They also explore the use of violence and logistics established on cryptomarkets in comparison to traditional dealing. To analyse the data we applied qualitative content analyses. Results: For conventional commercial illicit drug dealing on various kinds of markets, trust between buyer and seller is a crucial issue, often emphasized by restricting deals to well-known persons. While this typically includes face-to-face contact, the opposite is true with online drug trading. It is characteristic of cryptomarkets that the parties involved in a transaction know neither the personal identity nor the physical location of one another. This is realised by using aliases, anonymising software, and cryptocurrencies for payments. Violence typically only plays a role in traditional drug dealing, but mostly, if at all, just as a latent threat for potential rule-breakers. Processing a transaction anonymously includes escrow services for the buyers, which makes trading more reliable, although they cannot completely prevent scamming. Furthermore, online drug marketplaces usually offer a customer feedback system that allows customers to rate vendors and review products. A positive vendor feedback helps building reputation and trust in such an online environment. With regard to logistics, most conventional small-scale dealers restrict their acts of selling to private surroundings to avoid encounters with law enforcement. In cryptomarkets, the purchased drugs are delivered by traditional postal services, sometimes to false addresses or to someone else's name to conceal the identity and address of the buyer. Conclusion: On virtual drug markets practices of building trust, conflict resolution and logistics is constantly evolving. They offer improved security solutions on the one hand while on the other hand scamming and fraud seem to be widely used on both online and conventional drug markets.

Where is Dmitry going? Framing 'migratory' decisions in the criminal underground

You Can Tell a Cybercriminal by the Company they Keep: A Framework to Infer the Relevance of Underground Communities to the Threat Landscape

Understanding and Predicting Private Interactions in Underground Forums

Entanglement: Cybercrime Connections of an Internet Marketing Forum Population

Understanding Online Migration Decisions Following the Banning of Radical Communities

Plunge into the Underworld: A Survey on Emergence of Darknet

The transparency paradox. Building trust, resolving disputes and optimising logistics on conventional and online drugs markets

Trust intermediary in a cryptomarket for illegal drugs

The Dark Web Privacy Dilemma: Linguistic Diversity, Talkativeness, and User Engagement on the Cryptomarket Forums

‘I know this whole market is based on the trust you put in me and I don’t take that lightly’: Trust, community and discourse in crypto-drug markets

Towards Automatic Discovery of Cybercrime Supply Chains

Early warning signals for predicting cryptomarket vendor success using dark net forum networks

Under the Underground: Predicting Private Interactions in Underground Forums

Drug dealers gone digital: using signalling theory to analyse criminal online personas and trust

Detecting criminal organizations in mobile phone networks

Towards digital organized crime and digital sociology of organized crime

The Art of Cybercrime Community Research

CARONTE: Crawling Adversarial Resources Over Non-Trusted, High-Profile Environments

Identifying key players in dark web marketplaces through Bitcoin transaction networks

Exploring Cybercriminal Activities, Behaviors and Profiles

Unraveling the Italian and English Telegram Conspiracy Spheres through Message Forwarding