Exploring the Generalization Capabilities of AID-based Bi-level Optimization

Congliang Chen,Li Shen,Zhiqiang Xu,Wei Liu,Zhi-Quan Luo,Peilin Zhao

2024-11-25

Abstract:Bi-level optimization has achieved considerable success in contemporary machine learning applications, especially for given proper hyperparameters. However, due to the two-level optimization structure, commonly, researchers focus on two types of bi-level optimization methods: approximate implicit differentiation (AID)-based and iterative differentiation (ITD)-based approaches. ITD-based methods can be readily transformed into single-level optimization problems, facilitating the study of their generalization capabilities. In contrast, AID-based methods cannot be easily transformed similarly but must stay in the two-level structure, leaving their generalization properties enigmatic. In this paper, although the outer-level function is nonconvex, we ascertain the uniform stability of AID-based methods, which achieves similar results to a single-level nonconvex problem. We conduct a convergence analysis for a carefully chosen step size to maintain stability. Combining the convergence and stability results, we give the generalization ability of AID-based bi-level optimization methods. Furthermore, we carry out an ablation study of the parameters and assess the performance of these methods on real-world tasks. Our experimental results corroborate the theoretical findings, demonstrating the effectiveness and potential applications of these methods.

Machine Learning

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the generalization ability of the Approximate Implicit Differentiation (AID - based) method in Bi - level Optimization. Specifically, the research focuses on the following points:

1. **Complexity of the bi - level optimization structure**: The bi - level optimization problem has an inner - outer two - layer optimization structure. The two common methods are Approximate Implicit Differentiation (AID) and Iterative Total Differentiation (ITD). The ITD method can be transformed into a single - layer optimization problem, which is convenient for analyzing its generalization ability; while the AID method, due to its dependence on the historical iterations of the inner and outer variables, is difficult to be directly transformed in a similar way, resulting in its generalization properties being still unclear.

2. **Stability analysis under non - convex outer functions**: Although the outer function is non - convex, by introducing a uniform stability framework, the paper proves that the AID method has uniform stability under specific conditions, and this stability is similar to that of single - layer non - convex optimization problems.

3. **Convergence and learning rate selection**: The paper makes a detailed selection and analysis of the step size (learning rate) to ensure that the algorithm can converge while maintaining stability. In particular, when the step size is set to \(O(1/t)\), the AID method can achieve results similar to single - loop non - convex optimization.

4. **Generalization error decomposition**: The paper decomposes the generalization error in the bi - level optimization problem into four parts, and through theoretical analysis reveals the trade - off relationship between the optimization error and the generalization gap.

5. **Experimental verification**: Through ablation studies and performance evaluations in practical tasks, the experimental results verify the effectiveness of the theoretical analysis and show the potential and advantages of the AID method in real - world applications.

### Summary

The main contributions of the paper include:
- Developing a new analysis framework for studying the uniform stability of multi - level variables in bi - level optimization.
- Revealing the uniform stability of the AID method under certain conditions, and its stability bound is similar to that of single - layer non - convex optimization and the ITD method.
- Combining the convergence analysis, revealing the trade - off relationship between the optimization error and the generalization gap, and providing practical guidance on how to manage and minimize these gaps.

Through these works, the paper provides a solid theoretical basis and practical guidance for understanding and improving the generalization ability of the AID method in bi - level optimization.