Decoding the Meaning of Success on Digital Labor Platforms: Worker-Centered Perspectives

Pyeonghwa Kim,Charis Asante-Agyei,Isabel Munoz,Michael Dunn,Steve Sawyer

2024-11-22

Abstract:What does work and career success mean for those who secure their work using digital labor platforms? Traditional research on success predominantly relies on organizationally-centric benchmarks, such as promotions and income. These measures provide limited insights into the evolving nature of work and careers shaped at the intersection of digital labor platform technologies and workers' evolving perspectives. Drawing on data from a longitudinal study of 108 digital labor platform workers on Upwork, we (1) identify seven dimensions of success indicators that reflect workers' definitions of success in platform-mediated work and careers, (2) delineate three dimensions of digital labor platforms mediating workers' experiences of success and (3) examine the shifting perspectives of these workers relative to success. Based on these findings, we discuss the implications of platform-mediated success in workers' labor experiences, marked by platformic management, standardization, precarity and ongoing evolution. Our discussion intertwines CSCW scholarship with career studies, advancing a more nuanced understanding of the evolving perspectives on success in platform-mediated work and careers.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How do freelancers working on digital labor platforms (such as Upwork) define and understand the success of work and career? Traditional research mainly relies on organization - centered measurement criteria, such as promotion and income, which cannot fully reflect the evolving nature of work and the changes in career under the interweaving of digital labor platform technology and the changing perspectives of workers.

Specifically, this paper aims to answer the following three research questions:

1. **RQ1: How do digital platform workers interpret career success?**
2. **RQ2: How does the digital labor platform shape these workers' interpretations of career success?**
3. **RQ3: How do these workers' interpretations of career success evolve over time?**

### Main research content

To answer these questions, the author conducted a multi - year longitudinal study and surveyed 108 freelancers on the Upwork platform. Through four rounds of interviews, surveys, and archival data collection, the author analyzed these freelancers' understanding and views of success and explored how platform design and technology affect their career experiences and success criteria.

### Research findings

Based on the research results, the author has drawn the following three main findings:

1. **Seven - dimensional subjective career success indicators**: Digital platform workers use seven dimensions to interpret their career success in platform - mediated work, including:
- **Financial Rewards**: Accounting for 29% of the total coded discourse.
- **Agency**: Accounting for 21%.
- **Interpersonal Relationships**: Accounting for 12%.
- **Fulfillment**: Accounting for 12%.
- **Self - Development**: Accounting for 8%.
- **Recognition**: Accounting for 7%.
- **Wellness**: Accounting for 6%.

2. **Three platform - mediated dimensions**: The platform affects workers' understanding of success through the following three dimensions:
- **Platformic Management**: How platform rules and policies affect workers' behaviors and expectations.
- **Standardization**: How the standardized tools and services provided by the platform affect workers' working methods.
- **Precarity**: How the uncertainty and risks brought by the platform affect workers' career security.

3. **Evolution of success criteria**: As workers accumulate experience on the platform, their views on success have changed. The author has identified two patterns:
- **Initial stage**: Newcomers to the platform are more concerned with financial rewards and agency.
- **Mature stage**: With the accumulation of experience, workers attach more importance to fulfillment, self - development, and interpersonal relationships.

### Conclusions and significance

This study reveals how workers on digital labor platforms redefine career success and emphasizes the crucial role played by platform design and technology in this process. The research results provide new insights for the fields of computer - supported cooperative work (CSCW) and career research, which are helpful for better understanding how digital labor platforms shape workers' career trajectories and success criteria.

### Formula representation

This article does not involve specific mathematical, physical, or chemical formulas, but the research methods and data analysis processes involved can be described using Markdown format. For example, the frequency distribution can be presented in tabular form:

```markdown
| Success dimension | Occurrence frequency (%) |
|------------------|--------------|
| Financial Rewards | 29 |
| Agency | 21 |
| Interpersonal Relationships | 12 |
| Fulfillment | 12 |
| Self - Development | 8 |
| Recognition | 7 |
| Wellness | 6 |
```