Calculating Profits and Losses for Algorithmic Trading Strategies: A Short Guide

James B. Glattfelder,Thomas Houweling

2024-11-21

Abstract:We present a series of equations that track the total realized and unrealized profits and losses at any time, incorporating the spread. The resulting formalism is ideally suited to evaluate the performance of trading model algorithms.

Trading and Market Microstructure

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Real Time-Cutting Algorithmic Trading

ZAID SAYYED,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.55041/ijsrem35766

2024-06-12

INTERANTIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH IN ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT

Abstract:a. Brief overview of algorithmic trading. Algorithmic trading, also known as algo trading or automated trading, refers to the use of computer algorithms and mathematical models to execute trading orders in financial markets. The primary goal of algorithmic trading is to achieve efficient and optimized execution of trading strategies, leveraging the speed and precision of computer systems. Here is a brief overview of algorithmic trading: 1. **Automation:** Algorithmic trading involves automating the process of buying or selling financial instruments, such as stocks, bonds, currencies, or commodities. The trading decisions are based on predefined rules and algorithms, eliminating the need for manual intervention. 2. **Speed:** One of the key advantages of algorithmic trading is its ability to execute trades at extremely high speeds. Algorithms can analyze market conditions, make decisions, and execute trades in a fraction of a second, responding to market changes much faster than human traders. 3. **Quantitative Analysis:** Algorithmic trading relies heavily on quantitative analysis and statistical models. Traders develop algorithms that are based on mathematical formulas, historical price data, technical indicators, and other relevant factors to identify trading opportunities. 4. **Market Making:** Some algorithmic trading strategies are designed for market making, where traders provide liquidity to the market by quoting bid and ask prices. Market-making algorithms aim to profit from the spread between the buying and selling prices. 5. **Arbitrage:** Algorithmic trading is often employed for arbitrage strategies, which involve exploiting price discrepancies between different markets or instruments. These discrepancies may arise due to inefficiencies, delays in information dissemination, or other market imperfections. 6. **Risk Management:** Algo trading systems typically incorporate risk management measures to control exposure and mitigate potential losses. These measures may include setting stop-loss orders, position sizing algorithms, and other risk controls. 7. **Backtesting:** Before deploying algorithms in live markets, traders often perform extensive backtesting. This involves running historical market data through the algorithm to simulate how it would have performed in the past. This helps refine and optimize the algorithm for real-world conditions. 8. **Machine Learning:** Some advanced algorithmic trading strategies incorporate machine learning techniques to adapt and learn from changing market conditions. Machine learning algorithms can analyze vast amounts of data to identify patterns and make predictions. 9. **Regulatory Considerations:** Algorithmic trading is subject to various regulations to ensure fair and orderly markets. Regulatory bodies may impose rules regarding algorithmic trading practices, transparency, and risk management to prevent market manipulation and protect investors. Algorithmic trading has become increasingly prevalent in financial markets, with institutional investors, hedge funds, and proprietary trading firms utilizing sophisticated algorithms to execute trades efficiently and capitalize on market opportunities.
The alpha life cycle of quantitative strategy

Yi Zhou,Jianwu Lin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/SII.2017.8279188

2017-01-01

Abstract:Recent research and trading activity indicate that after the publication of some strategies and crowded trading, the strategies' performance will keep declining, which is called alpha decay. This paper tries to model the process by behavioral finance theory and active portfolio management theory. We will introduce gambler's ruin problem and use a simple model to rebuild the market structure, divide the market participants into two part: the rational investors and the noise traders. The model will explain the source of alpha and the proportion changes of the two kinds of investor will influence the profitability of alphas, which displays Alpha Life Cycle. Through periodic analysis of the phenomenon of alpha, investors can identify their investment strategies' the position in the life cycle, which will help portfolio management with multiple quantitative strategies, select strategies which in early positions of life cycles, so that their portfolios can maintain long-term excess returns.
Learning the dynamics of technical trading strategies

Nicholas Murphy,Tim Gebbie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14697688.2020.1869292

2019-12-25

Abstract:We use an adversarial expert based online learning algorithm to learn the optimal parameters required to maximise wealth trading zero-cost portfolio strategies. The learning algorithm is used to determine the relative population dynamics of technical trading strategies that can survive historical back-testing as well as form an overall aggregated portfolio trading strategy from the set of underlying trading strategies implemented on daily and intraday Johannesburg Stock Exchange data. The resulting population time-series are investigated using unsupervised learning for dimensionality reduction and visualisation. A key contribution is that the overall aggregated trading strategies are tested for statistical arbitrage using a novel hypothesis test proposed by Jarrow et al. (2012) on both daily sampled and intraday time-scales. The (low frequency) daily sampled strategies fail the arbitrage tests after costs, while the (high frequency) intraday sampled strategies are not falsified as statistical arbitrages after costs. The estimates of trading strategy success, cost of trading and slippage are considered along with an online benchmark portfolio algorithm for performance comparison. In addition, the algorithms generalisation error is analysed by recovering a probability of back-test overfitting estimate using a nonparametric procedure introduced by Bailey et al. (2016). The work aims to explore and better understand the interplay between different technical trading strategies from a data-informed perspective.

Computational Finance,Trading and Market Microstructure,Machine Learning
Algorithmic Trading in Practice

Peter Gomber,Kai Zimmermann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199844371.013.12

2018-02-05

Abstract:The use of computer algorithms in securities trading, or algorithmic trading, has become a central factor in modern financial markets. The desire for cost and time savings within the trading industry spurred buy side as well as sell side institutions to implement algorithmic services along the entire securities trading value chain. This chapter encompasses this algorithmic evolution, highlighting key cornerstones in it development discussing main trading strategies, and summarizing implications for overall securities markets quality. In addition, it touches on the contribution of algorithmic trading to the recent market turmoil, the U.S. Flash Crash, including the discussions of potential solutions for assuring market reliability and integrity.
Le trading algorithmique

Victor Lebreton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0810.4000

2009-03-19

Abstract:The algorithmic trading comes from digitalisation of the processing of trading assets on financial markets. Since 1980 the computerization of the stock market offers real time processing of financial information. This technological revolution has offered processes and mathematic methods to identify best return on transactions. Current research relates to autonomous transaction systems programmed in certain periods and some algorithms. This offers return opportunities where traders can not intervene. There are about thirty algorithms to assist the traders, the best known are the VWAP, the TWAP, TVOL. The algorithms offer the latest strategies and decision-making are the subject of much research. These advances in modeling decision-making autonomous agent can envisage a rich future for these technologies, the players already in use for more than 30% of their trading.

Trading and Market Microstructure,General Literature
Realtime market microstructure analysis: online Transaction Cost Analysis

Robert Azencott,Arjun Beri,Yutheeka Gadhyan,Nicolas Joseph,Charles-Albert Lehalle,Matthew Rowley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1302.6363

2013-03-01

Abstract:Motivated by the practical challenge in monitoring the performance of a large number of algorithmic trading orders, this paper provides a methodology that leads to automatic discovery of the causes that lie behind a poor trading performance. It also gives theoretical foundations to a generic framework for real-time trading analysis. Academic literature provides different ways to formalize these algorithms and show how optimal they can be from a mean-variance, a stochastic control, an impulse control or a statistical learning viewpoint. This paper is agnostic about the way the algorithm has been built and provides a theoretical formalism to identify in real-time the market conditions that influenced its efficiency or inefficiency. For a given set of characteristics describing the market context, selected by a practitioner, we first show how a set of additional derived explanatory factors, called anomaly detectors, can be created for each market order. We then will present an online methodology to quantify how this extended set of factors, at any given time, predicts which of the orders are underperforming while calculating the predictive power of this explanatory factor set. Armed with this information, which we call influence analysis, we intend to empower the order monitoring user to take appropriate action on any affected orders by re-calibrating the trading algorithms working the order through new parameters, pausing their execution or taking over more direct trading control. Also we intend that use of this method in the post trade analysis of algorithms can be taken advantage of to automatically adjust their trading action.

Trading and Market Microstructure,Information Theory,Statistics Theory
A closed-form solution for optimal mean-reverting trading strategies

Alexander Lipton,Marcos Lopez de Prado

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2003.10502

2020-03-24

Abstract:When prices reflect all available information, they oscillate around an equilibrium level. This oscillation is the result of the temporary market impact caused by waves of buyers and sellers. This price behavior can be approximated through an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck (O-U) process. Market makers provide liquidity in an attempt to monetize this oscillation. They enter a long position when a security is priced below its estimated equilibrium level, and they enter a short position when a security is priced above its estimated equilibrium level. They hold that position until one of three outcomes occur: (1) they achieve the targeted profit; (2) they experience a maximum tolerated loss; (3) the position is held beyond a maximum tolerated horizon. All market makers are confronted with the problem of defining profit-taking and stop-out levels. More generally, all execution traders acting on behalf of a client must determine at what levels an order must be fulfilled. Those optimal levels can be determined by maximizing the trader's Sharpe ratio in the context of O-U processes via Monte Carlo experiments. This paper develops an analytical framework and derives those optimal levels by using the method of heat potentials.

Trading and Market Microstructure,Mathematical Finance
Handling losses in translog profit models

J. W. B. Bos,M. Koetter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00036840802570413

IF: 1.916

2011-02-01

Applied Economics

Abstract:In this article, we compare standard approaches used to handle losses in logarithmic profit models with a simple novel approach. We estimate translog stochastic profit frontiers, and discuss discriminatory power, rank stability and the precision of Profit Efficiency (PE) scores. Contrary to existing methods, our approach does not result in a loss of observations. Our new method enhances rank stability and discriminatory power, and improves the precision of PE scores.

economics
Fractal Profit Landscape of the Stock Market

Andreas Gronlund,Il Gu Yi,Beom Jun Kim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1205.0505

2012-05-02

Statistical Finance

Abstract:We investigate the structure of the profit landscape obtained from the most basic, fluctuation based, trading strategy applied for the daily stock price data. The strategy is parameterized by only two variables, p and q. Stocks are sold and bought if the log return is bigger than p and less than -q, respectively. Repetition of this simple strategy for a long time gives the profit defined in the underlying two-dimensional parameter space of p and q. It is revealed that the local maxima in the profit landscape are spread in the form of a fractal structure. The fractal structure implies that successful strategies are not localized to any region of the profit landscape and are neither spaced evenly throughout the profit landscape, which makes the optimization notoriously hard and hypersensitive for partial or limited information. The concrete implication of this property is demonstrated by showing that optimization of one stock for future values or other stocks renders worse profit than a strategy that ignores fluctuations, i.e., a long-term buy-and-hold strategy.
Efficient Computation of Optimal Trading Strategies

Victor Boyarshinov,Malik Magdon-Ismail

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1009.4683

2010-09-23

Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science

Abstract:Given the return series for a set of instruments, a \emph{trading strategy} is a switching function that transfers wealth from one instrument to another at specified times. We present efficient algorithms for constructing (ex-post) trading strategies that are optimal with respect to the total return, the Sterling ratio and the Sharpe ratio. Such ex-post optimal strategies are useful analysis tools. They can be used to analyze the "profitability of a market" in terms of optimal trading; to develop benchmarks against which real trading can be compared; and, within an inductive framework, the optimal trades can be used to to teach learning systems (predictors) which are then used to identify future trading opportunities.
How brokers can optimally plot against traders

Manuel Lafond

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1605.04949

2022-06-02

Abstract:Traders buy and sell financial instruments in hopes of making profit, and brokers are responsible for the transaction. There are several hypotheses and conspiracy theories arguing that in some situations, brokers want their traders to lose money. For instance, a broker may want to protect the positions of a privileged customer. Another example is that some brokers take positions opposite to their traders', in which case they make money whenever their traders lose money. These are reasons for which brokers might manipulate prices in order to maximize the losses of their traders. In this paper, our goal is to perform this shady task optimally -- or at least to check whether this can actually be done algorithmically. Assuming total control over the price of an asset (ignoring the usual aspects of finance such as market conditions, external influence or stochasticity), we show how in quadratic time, given a set of trades specified by a stop-loss and a take-profit price, a broker can find a maximum loss price movement. We also look at an online trade model where broker and trader exchange turns, each trying to make a profit. We show in which condition either side can make a profit, and that the best option for the trader is to never trade.

Trading and Market Microstructure
Following a Trend with an Exponential Moving Average: Analytical Results for a Gaussian Model

D. S. Grebenkov,J. Serror

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2013.10.007

2013-08-27

Abstract:We investigate how price variations of a stock are transformed into profits and losses (P&Ls) of a trend following strategy. In the frame of a Gaussian model, we derive the probability distribution of P&Ls and analyze its moments (mean, variance, skewness and kurtosis) and asymptotic behavior (quantiles). We show that the asymmetry of the distribution (with often small losses and less frequent but significant profits) is reminiscent to trend following strategies and less dependent on peculiarities of price variations. At short times, trend following strategies admit larger losses than one may anticipate from standard Gaussian estimates, while smaller losses are ensured at longer times. Simple explicit formulas characterizing the distribution of P&Ls illustrate the basic mechanisms of momentum trading, while general matrix representations can be applied to arbitrary Gaussian models. We also compute explicitly annualized risk adjusted P&L and strategy turnover to account for transaction costs. We deduce the trend following optimal timescale and its dependence on both auto-correlation level and transaction costs. Theoretical results are illustrated on the Dow Jones index.

Statistical Finance,Statistical Mechanics
Exploring Efficient Quantitative Trading Strategies: A Comprehensive Comparison of Momentum, SMAs and Machine Learning

Liran Duan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54254/2754-1169/86/20240940

2024-05-28

Abstract:To provide an objective analysis, this study examines three quantitative trading strategies: Momentum, Moving Average Crossover, and Machine Learning individually but in a common methodological setting. In order to achieve higher returns at lower levels of risk due to the advent of algorithmic trading, such strategies must be explored. The two strategies that we analyze include the Momentum strategy that capitalizes on the persistence in price trends and the Moving Average Crossover strategy that relies on average price movements as trading signals. In addition, in this study, Machine Learning methods are applied which implement predictive algorithms to predict the price movements in the future based on their historical patterns. In order to assess the performance of each strategy, this investigation relies on one data set and uses a series of financial metrics to see how well each strategy performs with the objective of identifying both strengths and weaknesses that these strategies exhibit within different market situations.
An Introduction To Regret Minimization In Algorithmic Trading: A Survey of Universal Portfolio Techniques

Thomas Orton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2105.13126

2021-05-26

Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science

Abstract:In financial investing, universal portfolios are a means of constructing portfolios which guarantee a certain level of performance relative to a baseline, while making no statistical assumptions about the future market data. They fall under the broad category of regret minimization algorithms. This document covers an introduction and survey to universal portfolio techniques, covering some of the basic concepts and proofs in the area. Topics include: Constant Rebalanced Portfolios, Cover's Algorithm, Incorporating Transaction Costs, Efficient Computation of Portfolios, Including Side Information, and Follow The Leader Algorithm.
151 Estrategias de Trading (151 Trading Strategies)

Zura Kakushadze,Juan Andrés Serur

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1912.04492

2019-11-14

General Finance

Abstract:This book, which is in Spanish, provides detailed descriptions, including over 550 mathematical formulas, for over 150 trading strategies across a host of asset classes (and trading styles). This includes stocks, options, fixed income, futures, ETFs, indexes, commodities, foreign exchange, convertibles, structured assets, volatility (as an asset class), real estate, distressed assets, cash, cryptocurrencies, miscellany (such as weather, energy, inflation), global macro, infrastructure, and tax arbitrage. Some strategies are based on machine learning algorithms (such as artificial neural networks, Bayes, k-nearest neighbors). We also give: source code for illustrating out-of-sample backtesting with explanatory notes; around 2,000 bibliographic references; and over 900 glossary, acronym and math definitions. The presentation is intended to be descriptive and pedagogical. ----- Este libro proporciona descripciones detalladas, que incluyen m\'as de 550 f\'ormulas matem\'aticas, para m\'as de 150 estrategias de trading para una gran cantidad de clases de activos y estilos de trading. Esto incluye acciones, opciones, bonos (renta fija), futuros, ETFs, \'indices, commodities, divisas, bonos convertibles, activos estructurados, volatilidad (como clase de activos), bienes inmuebles, activos en distress, efectivo, criptomonedas, miscel\'aneos (como clima, energ\'ia, inflaci\'on), macro global, infraestructura y arbitraje impositivo. Algunas estrategias se basan en algoritmos de aprendizaje autom\'atico (como redes neuronales artificiales, Bayes, k vecinos m\'as cercanos). El libro tambi\'en incluye c\'odigo para backtesting fuera de la muestra con notas explicativas; cerca de 2,000 referencias bibliogr\'aficas; m\'as de 900 t\'erminos que comprenden el glosario, acr\'onimos y definiciones matem\'aticas. La presentaci\'on pretende ser descriptiva y pedag\'ogica.
An overall view of key problems in algorithmic trading and recent progress

Michaël Karpe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2006.05515

2020-06-10

Abstract:We summarize the fundamental issues at stake in algorithmic trading, and the progress made in this field over the last twenty years. We first present the key problems of algorithmic trading, describing the concepts of optimal execution, optimal placement, and price impact. We then discuss the most recent advances in algorithmic trading through the use of Machine Learning, discussing the use of Deep Learning, Reinforcement Learning, and Generative Adversarial Networks.

Trading and Market Microstructure
Composing Ensembles of Instrument-Model Pairs for Optimizing Profitability in Algorithmic Trading

Sahand Hassanizorgabad

2024-11-07

Abstract:Financial markets are nonlinear with complexity, where different types of assets are traded between buyers and sellers, each having a view to maximize their Return on Investment (ROI). Forecasting market trends is a challenging task since various factors like stock-specific news, company profiles, public sentiments, and global economic conditions influence them. This paper describes a daily price directional predictive system of financial instruments, addressing the difficulty of predicting short-term price movements. This paper will introduce the development of a novel trading system methodology by proposing a two-layer Composing Ensembles architecture, optimized through grid search, to predict whether the price will rise or fall the next day. This strategy was back-tested on a wide range of financial instruments and time frames, demonstrating an improvement of 20% over the benchmark, representing a standard investment strategy.

Trading and Market Microstructure,Artificial Intelligence,Machine Learning
Costly Trading

Michael Isichenko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2110.15239

2021-10-07

Abstract:We revisit optimal execution of an active portfolio in the presence of slippage (aka linear, proportional, or absolute-value) costs. Market efficiency implies a close balance between active alphas and trading costs, so even small changes to trading optimization can make a big difference. It has been observed for some time that optimal trading involves a pattern of a no-trade zone with width $\Delta$ increasing with slippage cost parameter $c$. In a setting of a reasonably stable (non-stochastic) forecast of future returns and a quadratic risk aversion, it is shown that $\Delta\sim c^{1/2}$, which differs from the $\Delta\sim c^{1/3}$ scaling reported for stochastic settings. Analysis of optimal trading employs maximization of a utility including projected alpha-based profits, slippage costs, and risk aversion and borrows from a physical analogy of forced motion in the presence of friction.

Portfolio Management,Trading and Market Microstructure
Decoding Stock Market with Quant Alphas

Zura Kakushadze,Willie Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1708.02984

2017-08-10

Abstract:We give an explicit algorithm and source code for extracting expected returns for stocks from expected returns for alphas. Our algorithm altogether bypasses combining alphas with weights into "alpha combos". Simply put, we have developed a new method for trading alphas which does not involve combining them. This yields substantial cost savings as alpha combos cost hedge funds around 3% of the P&L, while alphas themselves cost around 10%. Also, the extra layer of alpha combos, which our new method avoids, adds noise and suboptimality. We also arrive at our algorithm independently by explicitly constructing alpha risk models based on position data.

Portfolio Management,Mathematical Finance,Risk Management

Calculating Profits and Losses for Algorithmic Trading Strategies: A Short Guide

Real Time-Cutting Algorithmic Trading

The alpha life cycle of quantitative strategy

Learning the dynamics of technical trading strategies

Algorithmic Trading in Practice

Le trading algorithmique

Realtime market microstructure analysis: online Transaction Cost Analysis

A closed-form solution for optimal mean-reverting trading strategies

Handling losses in translog profit models

Fractal Profit Landscape of the Stock Market

Efficient Computation of Optimal Trading Strategies

How brokers can optimally plot against traders

Following a Trend with an Exponential Moving Average: Analytical Results for a Gaussian Model

Exploring Efficient Quantitative Trading Strategies: A Comprehensive Comparison of Momentum, SMAs and Machine Learning

An Introduction To Regret Minimization In Algorithmic Trading: A Survey of Universal Portfolio Techniques

151 Estrategias de Trading (151 Trading Strategies)

An overall view of key problems in algorithmic trading and recent progress

Composing Ensembles of Instrument-Model Pairs for Optimizing Profitability in Algorithmic Trading

Costly Trading

Decoding Stock Market with Quant Alphas