Comparisons of multivariate contribution measures of risk contagion and their applications in cryptocurrency market

Limin Wen,Junxue Li,Tong Pu,Yiying Zhang
2024-11-20
Abstract:Conditional risk measures and their associated risk contribution measures are commonly employed in finance and actuarial science for evaluating systemic risk and quantifying the effects of risk contagion. This paper introduces various types of contribution measures based on the MCoVaR, MCoES, and MMME studied in Ortega-Jiménez et al. (2021) and Das & Fasen-Hartmann (2018) to assess both the absolute and relative effects of a single risk when other risks in a group are in distress. The properties of these contribution risk measures are examined, and sufficient conditions for comparing these measures between two sets of random vectors are established using univariate and multivariate stochastic orders and stochastic dependence notions. Numerical examples are presented for validating the conditions. Finally, a real dataset from the cryptocurrency market is also utilized to analyze the contagion effect in terms of our proposed contribution measures.
Risk Management
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to evaluate and quantify the impact of systemic risk contagion in a multivariate environment, especially in the application in the cryptocurrency market. Specifically, the article introduces multiple contribution measurement methods based on MCoVaR (Multivariate Conditional Value - at - Risk), MCoES (Multivariate Conditional Expected Shortfall) and MMME (Multivariate Marginal Mean Excess) to evaluate the absolute and relative impacts of a single risk when other risks are in distress. ### Main Problems and Solutions 1. **Limitations of Traditional Risk Measures** - Traditional risk measures such as VaR (Value - at - Risk) and ES (Expected Shortfall) cannot effectively quantify systemic risk because they only consider the risk of a single economic entity. - New conditional risk measures (co - risk measures) are required to quantify and evaluate systemic risk in the financial system. 2. **The Need for Multivariate Systemic Risk Measures** - In reality, multiple risks may occur simultaneously, and existing systemic risk measurement methods have difficulty dealing with this situation. - Introduce multivariate systemic risk measures (such as MCoVaR, MCoES and MMME) to more comprehensively evaluate the mutual influence among multiple risks. 3. **Definition and Comparison of Contribution Measures** - Propose two types of multivariate contribution risk measures: difference - based contribution measures and ratio - based contribution measures. - Use univariate and multivariate stochastic order theories and the concept of stochastic dependence to establish sufficient conditions for comparing different sets of risk vectors. 4. **Verification of Practical Applications** - Verify the effectiveness and applicability of the proposed contribution measures through numerical examples and empirical data in the cryptocurrency market. ### Formula Representation - **MCoVaR**: \[ \text{MCoVaR}_{\mathbf{p}}[X_1 | X_2, \ldots, X_n] = \text{VaR}_{p_1} \left[ X_1 \mid \bigcap_{j = 2}^n \{ X_j > \text{VaR}_{p_j}[X_j] \} \right] \] - **MCoES**: \[ \text{MCoES}_{\mathbf{p}}[X_1 | X_2, \ldots, X_n] = \frac{1}{1 - p_1} \int_{p_1}^1 \text{MCoVaR}_{t, p_2, \ldots, p_n}[X_1 | X_2, \ldots, X_n] \, dt \] - **MMME**: \[ \text{MMME}_{\mathbf{p}[-1]}[X_1 | X_2, \ldots, X_n] = \mathbb{E} \left[ \left( X_1 - A_{X, \mathbf{p}[-1]} \right)^+ \mid \bigcap_{j = 2}^n \{ X_j > \text{VaR}_{p_j}[X_j] \} \right] \] where \( A_{X, \mathbf{p}[-1]}=\sum_{i = 2}^n a_i \text{VaR}_{p_i}[X_i] \) and \( \sum_{i = 2}^n a_i = 1 \). ### Conclusion This paper provides new tools and perspectives for evaluating and quantifying systemic risk contagion by introducing and analyzing multivariate contribution measurement methods, especially applicable to complex financial environments such as the cryptocurrency market.