Fine-Grained Uncertainty Quantification via Collisions

Jesse Friedbaum,Sudarshan Adiga,Ravi Tandon
2024-11-19
Abstract:We propose a new approach for fine-grained uncertainty quantification (UQ) using a collision matrix. For a classification problem involving $K$ classes, the $K\times K$ collision matrix $S$ measures the inherent (aleatoric) difficulty in distinguishing between each pair of classes. In contrast to existing UQ methods, the collision matrix gives a much more detailed picture of the difficulty of classification. We discuss several possible downstream applications of the collision matrix, establish its fundamental mathematical properties, as well as show its relationship with existing UQ methods, including the Bayes error rate. We also address the new problem of estimating the collision matrix using one-hot labeled data. We propose a series of innovative techniques to estimate $S$. First, we learn a contrastive binary classifier which takes two inputs and determines if they belong to the same class. We then show that this contrastive classifier (which is PAC learnable) can be used to reliably estimate the Gramian matrix of $S$, defined as $G=S^TS$. Finally, we show that under very mild assumptions, $G$ can be used to uniquely recover $S$, a new result on stochastic matrices which could be of independent interest. Experimental results are also presented to validate our methods on several datasets.
Machine Learning,Information Theory,Statistics Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to develop a new method to achieve fine - grained uncertainty quantification (UQ), especially in classification problems. Specifically, the author proposes a method based on the **Collision Matrix** to measure the aleatoric uncertainty between different classes. ### 1. Research Background and Motivation With the application of machine learning in high - risk and high - uncertainty scenarios (such as healthcare and finance), the demand for uncertainty quantification (UQ) in classification tasks is increasing. Traditional UQ methods usually can only provide overall uncertainty measures and cannot describe the differences between classes in detail. This limits their effectiveness in some application scenarios. ### 2. The Proposed New Method To overcome this limitation, the author proposes the **Collision Matrix**. The Collision Matrix is a \( K\times K \) matrix \( S \), where \( K \) is the number of classes. The \((i, j)\) - th element \( S_{i,j}\) of the matrix represents the probability that when a feature vector is observed to belong to class \( j \), it is again observed to belong to class \( i \). In other words, \( S_{i,j}\) describes the degree of confusion between class \( i \) and class \( j \). ### 3. Main Contributions - **Defining the Collision Matrix**: The author strictly defines the Collision Matrix and shows how it can be described by the probability density function (pdf) of the data distribution. - **Interpreting the Collision Matrix**: The Collision Matrix can be regarded as the expected confusion matrix of the Probabilistic Bayes Classifier (PBC), which enables it to be related to the Bayes Error Rate (BER). - **Estimating the Collision Matrix**: The author proposes a novel technique to estimate the Collision Matrix, using a contrastive binary classifier to reliably estimate the Gramian matrix \( G = S^{T}S \) and proves that \( S \) can be recovered from \( G \) under certain conditions. - **Experimental Verification**: The author conducts numerical evaluations on multiple synthetic and real - world datasets to verify the effectiveness of their method. ### 4. Application Prospects The Collision Matrix provides a more detailed description of classification difficulty than existing UQ methods and can help researchers and practitioners better understand the uncertainty in classification tasks. For example, in medical diagnosis, the Collision Matrix can help identify which diseases are difficult to distinguish, thereby guiding doctors to make more accurate diagnoses or improve classification models. ### Summary The main goal of this paper is to provide a fine - grained uncertainty quantification method by introducing the Collision Matrix to better understand and handle the uncertainty in classification tasks. This method can not only reveal the confusion between classes but also provide valuable insights for improving classification models.