Mapping out the Space of Human Feedback for Reinforcement Learning: A Conceptual Framework

Yannick Metz,David Lindner,Raphaël Baur,Mennatallah El-Assady

2024-11-19

Abstract:Reinforcement Learning from Human feedback (RLHF) has become a powerful tool to fine-tune or train agentic machine learning models. Similar to how humans interact in social contexts, we can use many types of feedback to communicate our preferences, intentions, and knowledge to an RL agent. However, applications of human feedback in RL are often limited in scope and disregard human factors. In this work, we bridge the gap between machine learning and human-computer interaction efforts by developing a shared understanding of human feedback in interactive learning scenarios. We first introduce a taxonomy of feedback types for reward-based learning from human feedback based on nine key dimensions. Our taxonomy allows for unifying human-centered, interface-centered, and model-centered aspects. In addition, we identify seven quality metrics of human feedback influencing both the human ability to express feedback and the agent's ability to learn from the feedback. Based on the feedback taxonomy and quality criteria, we derive requirements and design choices for systems learning from human feedback. We relate these requirements and design choices to existing work in interactive machine learning. In the process, we identify gaps in existing work and future research opportunities. We call for interdisciplinary collaboration to harness the full potential of reinforcement learning with data-driven co-adaptive modeling and varied interaction mechanics.

Machine Learning,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the application of human feedback in reinforcement learning. Specifically, the authors aim to address the following two core research questions:

1. **What different types of human feedback exist?**
- The paper proposes a taxonomy of human feedback, which provides a structured description of human feedback based on nine dimensions. These dimensions cover human - centered, interface - centered, and model - centered aspects, thus providing a basis for classifying existing feedback patterns in human - AI interactions. In addition, the author also formally defines the form of human feedback.

2. **What is high - quality human feedback?**
- To evaluate the effectiveness of human feedback, the author discusses seven quality indicators and explores their manifestations and measurement methods. These seven quality indicators synthesize the quality criteria reported in a wide range of literature and aim to comprehensively evaluate the quality of feedback from the perspectives of humans, interfaces, and models.

By solving the above problems, the authors hope to provide guidance for the design and development of reinforcement learning systems integrating human feedback, including requirements for user interface design, processing procedures, and reward modeling. In addition, the authors also point out the deficiencies in existing research and propose future research opportunities, calling for interdisciplinary cooperation to fully realize the potential of reinforcement learning in data - driven co - adaptive modeling and diverse interaction mechanisms.