Abstract:Abstract To analyse climate change mitigation strategies, economists rely on simplified climate models—so-called climate emulators—that provide a realistic quantitative link between CO2 emissions and global warming at low computational costs. In this paper, we propose a generic and transparent calibration and evaluation strategy for these climate emulators that are based on freely and easily accessible state-of-the-art benchmark data from climate sciences. We demonstrate that the appropriate choice of the free model parameters can be of key relevance for the predicted social cost of carbon. The key idea we put forward is to calibrate the simplified climate models to benchmark data from comprehensive global climate models that took part in the coupled model intercomparison project, phase 5 (CMIP5). In particular, we propose to use four different test cases that are considered pivotal in the climate science literature: two highly idealized tests to separately calibrate and evaluate the carbon cycle and temperature response, an idealized test to quantify the transient climate response, and a final test to evaluate the performance for scenarios close to those arising from economic models, and that include exogenous forcing. As a concrete example, we re-calibrate the climate part of the widely used DICE-2016, fathoming the CMIP5 uncertainty range of model responses: the multi-model mean as well as extreme, but still permissible climate sensitivities and carbon cycle responses. We demonstrate that the functional form of the climate emulator of the DICE-2016 model is fit for purpose, despite its simplicity, but its carbon cycle and temperature equations are miscalibrated, leading to the conclusion that one may want to be skeptical about predictions derived from DICE-2016. We examine the importance of the calibration for the social cost of carbon in the context of a partial equilibrium setting where interest rates are exogenous, as well as the simple general equilibrium setting from DICE-2016. We find that the model uncertainty from different consistent calibrations of the climate system can change the social cost of carbon by a factor of 4 if one assumes a quadratic damage function. When calibrated to the multi-model mean, our model predicts similar values for the social cost of carbon as the original DICE-2016, but with a strongly reduced sensitivity to the discount rate and about 1 degree less long-term warming. The social cost of carbon in DICE-2016 is oversensitive to the discount rate, leading to extreme comparative statics responses to changes in preferences.

Building Interpretable Climate Emulators for Economics

The Climate in Climate Economics

FaIRGP: A Bayesian Energy Balance Model for Surface Temperatures Emulation

Towards Causal Representations of Climate Model Data

Large-scale Emulation of Spatio-Temporal Variation in Temperature under Climate Change

Emulating mean patterns and variability of temperature across and within scenarios in anthropogenic climate change experiments

emIAM v1.0: an emulator for Integrated Assessment Models using marginal abatement cost curves

From emission scenarios to spatially resolved projections with a chain of computationally efficient emulators: coupling of MAGICC (v7.5.1) and MESMER (v0.8.3)

Building Ocean Climate Emulators

PACER: Physics Informed Uncertainty Aware Climate Emulator

Thermoeconomic Modeling as a Tool for Internalizing Carbon Credits into Multiproduct System Analysis

Transferability and explainability of deep learning emulators for regional climate model projections: Perspectives for future applications

Environmental impact assessment for climate change policy with the simulation-based integrated assessment model E3ME-FTT-GENIE

ACE: A fast, skillful learned global atmospheric model for climate prediction

DiffESM: Conditional Emulation of Temperature and Precipitation in Earth System Models with 3D Diffusion Models

Diffusion-Based Joint Temperature and Precipitation Emulation of Earth System Models

A Simple Climate-Solow Model for Introducing the Economics of Climate Change to Undergraduate Students

ACE2-SOM: Coupling an ML atmospheric emulator to a slab ocean and learning the sensitivity of climate to changed CO$_2$

Modeling myths: On DICE and dynamic realism in integrated assessment models of climate change mitigation

Long-Term Climate Change Commitment And Reversibility: An Emic Intercomparison