Abstract:BACKGROUND In the era of increasing tools for automatic image analysis in dermatology, new machine learning models require high-quality image data sets. Facial image data are needed for developing models to evaluate attributes such as redness (acne and rosacea models), texture (wrinkles and aging models), pigmentation (melasma, seborrheic keratoses, aging, and postinflammatory hyperpigmentation), and skin lesions. Deidentifying facial images is critical for protecting patient anonymity. Traditionally, journals have required facial feature concealment typically covering the eyes, but these guidelines are largely insufficient to meet ethical and legal guidelines of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act for patient privacy. Currently, facial feature deidentification is a challenging task given lack of expert consensus and lack of testing infrastructure for adequate automatic and manual facial image detection. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to review the current literature on automatic facial deidentification algorithms and to assess their utility in dermatology use cases, defined by preservation of skin attributes (redness, texture, pigmentation, and lesions) and data utility. METHODS We conducted a systematic search using a combination of headings and keywords to encompass the concepts of facial deidentification and privacy preservation. The MEDLINE (via PubMed), Embase (via Elsevier), and Web of Science (via Clarivate) databases were queried from inception to May 1, 2021. Studies with the incorrect design and outcomes were excluded during the screening and review process. RESULTS A total of 18 studies, largely focusing on general adversarial network (GANs), were included in the final review reporting various methodologies of facial deidentification algorithms for still and video images. GAN-based studies were included owing to the algorithm’s capacity to generate high-quality, realistic images. Study methods were rated individually for their utility for use cases in dermatology, pertaining to skin color or pigmentation and texture preservation, data utility, and human detection, by 3 human reviewers. We found that most studies notable in the literature address facial feature and expression preservation while sacrificing skin color, texture, pigmentation, which are critical features in dermatology-related data utility. CONCLUSIONS Overall, facial deidentification algorithms have made notable advances such as disentanglement and face swapping techniques, while producing realistic faces for protecting privacy. However, they are sparse and currently not suitable for complete preservation of skin texture, color, and pigmentation quality in facial photographs. Using the current advances in artificial intelligence for facial deidentification summarized herein, a novel approach is needed to ensure greater patient anonymity, while increasing data access for automated image analysis in dermatology.

Face De-identification: State-of-the-art Methods and Comparative Studies

Personalized and Invertible Face De-identification by Disentangled Identity Information Manipulation

Achieving Privacy-Preserving Multi-View Consistency with Advanced 3D-Aware Face De-identification.

A Systematical Solution for Face De-identification

IdentityDP: Differential Private Identification Protection for Face Images

Face De-Identification Using Face Caricature

A Hybrid Model for Natural Face De-Identiation with Adjustable Privacy

Privacy-Protective-GAN for Privacy Preserving Face De-Identification

Disguise without Disruption: Utility-Preserving Face De-Identification

Hiding among Your Neighbors: Face Image Privacy Protection with Differential Private K-Anonymity

HFORD: High-Fidelity and Occlusion-Robust De-identification for Face Privacy Protection.

Effective De-identification Generative Adversarial Network for Face Anonymization

AnonymousNet: Natural Face De-Identification With Measurable Privacy

Generating De-identification facial images based on the attention models and adversarial examples

Private Face Image Generation Method Based on Deidentification in Low Light

Manipulable, reversible and diversified de-identification via face identity disentanglement

Controllable Identity De-Identification for Face Image

Quantifying Privacy Levels of Faces in Images

EPD-Net: A GAN-based Architecture for Face De-identification from Images

Privacy Protection With Facial Deidentification Machine Learning Methods: Can Current Methods Be Applied to Dermatology? (Preprint)

Privacy preservation through facial de-identification with simultaneous emotion preservation