Abstract:Kaluza-Klein theory, by which we mean vacuum gravity in 5-dimensions, with asymptotics that are a product of a circle with Minkowski spacetime, has a variety of different static black hole solutions; localized black holes and the homogeneous and inhomogeneous black strings. There is currently no uniqueness theorem for the solutions, and for fixed circle size multiple solutions with the same mass co-exist. Intuitively for small circle sizes we might expect the theory truncates to become 4-dimensional, and correspondingly the only black holes are the homogeneous black strings. Thus we conjecture that for fixed mass and sufficiently small circle size, the only black holes are homogeneous ones. Here we give evidence that this is indeed the case. Firstly we introduce a toy scalar field model with a potential that allows tachyonic behaviour. Putting this theory on a product of Minkowski with a circle gives an analogous set of static homogeneous and inhomogeneous solutions to that of the black holes. We prove that solutions must be homogeneous for small circle sizes, the analog of our conjecture for this toy model. A weaker statement that is straightforward to derive is a bound on how inhomogeneous a solution can be - putting this scalar theory in a large but finite cavity, a norm of the wavefunction of the Kaluza-Klein modes can be shown to vanish in the small circle limit. Turning to the full gravitational theory, we employ a metric ansatz that imposes static axisymmetry, encompasses the homogeneous and inhomogeneous black strings (but not the localized solutions) and allows us to measure inhomogeneity of a solution. Employing a finite cavity and imposing boundary conditions that are compatible with homogeneity we show a similar result; the norm of certain Kaluza-Klein modes is bounded by the circle size, providing evidence that our conjecture is true.

Birkhoff's Theorem and Uniqueness: A Peak Beyond General Relativity

Uniqueness of the extremal Schwarzschild de Sitter spacetime

Uniqueness of the static vacuum asymptotically flat spacetimes with massive particle spheres

Kleinian black holes

Black holes in classical general relativity and beyond

Uniqueness of extremal charged black holes in de Sitter

Breaking black-hole uniqueness at supermassive scales

Non-Existence of Multiple-Black-Hole Solutions Close to Kerr–Newman

Towards a uniqueness theorem for static black holes in Kaluza-Klein theory with small circle size

The asymptotic expansion of the spacetime metric at the event horizon

Black Holes and Wormholes Beyond Classical General Relativity

On Birkhoff's theorem in ghost-free bimetric theory

Exploring the Applicability of Birkhoff's Theorem in Jackiw-Teitelboim Gravity

Topological and Geometric Properties of Spherically Symmetric Black Hole Metrics: Connections to Bose-Einstein Condensation and Uniqueness in Einstein Gravity

Null geodesic structure for the Barriola-Vilenkin spacetime via $k$-essence

Universal black hole solutions for all F(R) gravitational theories

Isolated Horizons: A Generalization of Black Hole Mechanics