From Simulators to Digital Twins for Enabling Emerging Cellular Networks: A Tutorial and Survey

Marvin Manalastas,Muhammad Umar Bin Farooq,Syed Muhammad Asad Zaidi,Haneya Naeem Qureshi,Yusuf Sambo,Ali Imran

2024-10-29

Abstract:Simulators are indispensable parts of the research and development necessary to advance countless industries, including cellular networks. With simulators, the evaluation, analysis, testing, and experimentation of novel designs and algorithms can be executed in a more cost-effective and convenient manner without the risk of real network service disruption. Additionally, recent trends indicate that the advancement of these Digital System Models (DSM), such as system-level simulators, will hold a pivotal role in advancing cellular networks by facilitating the development of digital twins. Given this growing significance, in this survey and tutorial paper, we present an extensive review of the currently available DSMs for 5G and beyond (5G&B) networks. Specifically, we begin with a tutorial on the fundamental concepts of 5G&B network simulations, followed by an identification of the essential design requirements needed to model the key features of these networks. We also devised a taxonomy of different types of 5G&B network simulators. In contrast to existing simulator surveys, which mostly leverage traditional metrics applicable to legacy networks, we devise and use 5G-specific evaluation metrics that capture three key facets of a network simulator, namely realism, completeness, and computational efficiency. We evaluate each simulator according to the devised metrics to generate an applicability matrix that maps different 5G&B simulators vis-a-vis the different research themes they can potentially enable. We also present the current challenges in developing 5G&B simulators while laying out several potential solutions to address the issues. Finally, we discuss the future challenges related to simulator design provisions that will arise with the emergence of 6G networks.

Networking and Internet Architecture,Systems and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to promote the transformation of emerging cellular networks (especially 5G and future 6G networks) to digital twin technology through the development and application of simulators**. Specifically, the paper aims to:

1. **Evaluate the applicability of existing simulators**: Through an extensive review of currently available digital system models (DSM), especially for 5G and future cellular networks, evaluate the potential of these simulators in achieving digital twins.

2. **Propose new evaluation metrics**: Different from traditional evaluation methods, the paper introduces three key evaluation criteria - **realism, completeness, computational efficiency** to more accurately measure the quality and applicability of simulators.

3. **Explore the transformation path from simulators to digital twins**: Analyze existing challenges and propose possible solutions to promote the development of simulators into tools that can support digital twins.

4. **Look forward to future requirements**: Discuss the new design requirements and challenges that digital system models will face with the emergence of 6G networks.

### Main contributions of the paper

1. **Comprehensive survey and analysis**: The paper conducts a detailed evaluation of more than 35 simulators at different levels (link - level, system - level, network - level), covering the latest tools in academia and industry.

2. **In - depth exploration of design requirements**: Analyze the characteristics of 5G and future cellular networks, propose key requirements in simulator design, and point out potential research directions.

3. **Innovative evaluation framework**: Propose new evaluation metrics based on the "iron triangle" (realism, completeness, computational efficiency), providing a scientific basis for the classification and selection of simulators.

4. **Framework for constructing digital twins**: Although the paper does not involve two - way feedback mechanisms, it proposes specific steps and necessary conditions for generating digital twins using DSM as a core component.

5. **Identify and address challenges**: Identify the main obstacles hindering the development of high - fidelity and efficient DSM, and propose corresponding solutions based on academic research and industrial practice to accelerate the transition to digital twins.

Through these efforts, the paper not only provides guidance for researchers to select appropriate simulation tools but also lays a theoretical and technical foundation for the development of future cellular networks.