Physics-Informed Transformation Toward Improving the Machine-Learned NLTE Models of ICF Simulations

Min Sang Cho,Paul E. Grabowski,Kowshik Thopalli,Thathachar S. Jayram,Michael J. Barrow,Jayaraman J. Thiagarajan,Rushil Anirudh,Hai P. Le,Howard A. Scott,Joshua B. Kallman,Branson C. Stephens,Mark E. Foord,Jim A. Gaffney,Peer-Timo Bremer
2024-11-14
Abstract:The integration of machine learning techniques into Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF) simulations has emerged as a powerful approach for enhancing computational efficiency. By replacing the costly Non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (NLTE) model with machine learning models, significant reductions in calculation time have been achieved. However, determining how to optimize machine learning-based NLTE models in order to match ICF simulation dynamics remains challenging, underscoring the need for physically relevant error metrics and strategies to enhance model accuracy with respect to these metrics. Thus, we propose novel physics-informed transformations designed to emphasize energy transport, use these transformations to establish new error metrics, and demonstrate that they yield smaller errors within reduced principal component spaces compared to conventional transformations.
Plasma Physics,Computational Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to optimize the machine - learning - based non - local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) model in inertial confinement fusion (ICF) simulations to better match the dynamic characteristics of ICF simulations. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Trade - off between computational efficiency and accuracy**: Although machine - learning techniques have significantly reduced the computational time of NLTE models, how to further optimize these machine - learning models to improve their accuracy for ICF simulation dynamics while maintaining computational efficiency remains a challenge. 2. **Lack of physically relevant error metrics**: The error metrics used in the training of existing machine - learning models may overlook physically important effects on ICF simulations. Therefore, new, physically relevant error - metric methods need to be developed to more accurately assess and optimize model performance. 3. **Impact of data processing**: The effects of different data - processing techniques (such as logarithmic transformation, cube - root transformation, etc.) on NLTE data have not been thoroughly studied, and the potential of these transformations has not been fully explored. The paper aims to solve these problems by introducing a new physical - information transformation (PhIT). ### Main contributions 1. **Proposing the physical - information transformation (PhIT)**: PhIT is a new data - transformation method that converts absorption coefficients and emissivities into variables that describe net energy exchange and the mean free path of photons. These variables can better reflect the physical processes in ICF simulations. 2. **Establishing new error metrics**: Based on the PhIT transformation, the paper proposes new error - metric methods that can more accurately assess the impact of data processing on radiative properties, thereby guiding model optimization. 3. **Verifying the effectiveness of the transformation**: Through methods such as principal component analysis (PCA), the paper demonstrates the superiority of the PhIT transformation in reducing errors, especially in reducing errors in important physical quantities such as Planck - mean absorption, Rosseland - mean absorption, and total emissivity. ### Specific implementation - **Physical background**: The paper details the radiation - hydrodynamics equations in ICF simulations, especially the radiation - transport equation and its closure conditions. - **Data generation**: Training data are generated using radiation - hydrodynamics codes (such as KULL), and these data cover the simulation results of copper targets under different laser - power multipliers. - **Transformation methods**: Two new physical variables, \(\delta_g\) and \(\tau_g\), are defined: - \(\delta_g=e_g - a_g\) represents net energy exchange. - \(\tau_g = \sigma\left(\frac{\ln(l_g)-\ln(l_{\text{max}}/l_{\text{min}})/2}{\ln(l_{\text{max}}/l_{\text{min}})}\right)\) represents the normalized form of the photon mean free path. - **Evaluation methods**: Through PCA analysis, the effects of different transformation methods (PhIT, logarithmic transformation, cube - root transformation) in reducing errors are compared. ### Conclusion By introducing the physical - information transformation (PhIT) and the corresponding error - metric methods, the paper significantly improves the accuracy and physical relevance of machine - learning models in ICF simulations. These methods not only reduce computational errors but also provide new tools and ideas for future ICF simulations.