Short note on the mapping of heritage sites impacted by the 2024 floods in Valencia, Spain

Josep Grau-Bove,Richard Higha,Scott Orr,Pakhee Kumar
2024-11-13
Abstract:This short note presents preliminary findings on the impact of the October 2024 floods on cultural heritage sites in Valencia, Spain. Using publicly available data, we assess the extent of potential damage by overlaying flood maps with heritage site coordinates. We identify that 3.3\% of heritage sites in the region have been potentially impacted, with churches and shrines (81), outdoor religious iconography (78), and historic irrigation features (45) being the most heavily affected. Our analysis utilizes data from OpenStreetMap and listings from the Generalitat Valenciana, suggesting that while OpenStreetMap's crowd-sourced data can provide useful estimates of the proportion of impacted sites, it may not be suitable for a detailed damage assessment. By sharing this data openly, we aim to contribute to international efforts in preserving cultural heritage after the disaster and provide a foundation for future assessments of heritage site vulnerability to climate-related events.
Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the impact of the Valencia flood in October 2024 on cultural heritage sites in Spain. Specifically, by using open data (such as OpenStreetMap and official records of the Valencia Autonomous Region), the author determines the number and types of cultural heritage sites that may be affected, and explores the effectiveness of these data sources in quickly assessing potential damage. ### Main problems 1. **Evaluating the impact of floods on cultural heritage**: - The author uses open data to evaluate the potential impact of the Valencia flood in October 2024 on cultural heritage sites. - By overlaying the flood map with the coordinates of cultural heritage sites, it is identified which sites may have been affected. 2. **Verifying the effectiveness of open - source data**: - One of the scientific goals of the study is to determine whether open - source, crowdsourced data (such as OpenStreetMap) can be used for the preliminary assessment of cultural heritage damage. - Whether these data sources are suitable for detailed damage assessment is also a problem to be explored. ### Method overview - **Data sources**: - Use the flood map provided by the Copernicus Emergency Management Service. - Obtain crowdsourced cultural heritage location and type data from OpenStreetMap. - Obtain the official list of cultural heritage from the Valencia Autonomous Region website. - **Analysis methods**: - Use ArcGIS software to overlay the cultural heritage coordinates on the flood map. - If a site is within 10 meters of the affected area, it is marked as potentially affected. ### Results - **Total number of affected sites**: - According to the most comprehensive official records (data from the Valencia Autonomous Region), 3.3% of cultural heritage sites are located within the affected area. - Among them, the most affected types include churches and sanctuaries (81), religious icons (78), and historical irrigation facilities (45). - **Effectiveness of open - source data**: - Although the data of OpenStreetMap is not as detailed as the official records, it performs well in estimating the proportion of affected sites. - Sampling using OpenStreetMap is a feasible method for quickly assessing the proportion of affected areas. ### Next steps - **Field confirmation**: - Confirm the actual situation of potentially damaged sites through field observations. - Invite local volunteers and online volunteers (such as the Wikimedia community) to participate in data collection. - **Further research**: - Compare the effects of different data sources to obtain a more accurate rapid assessment method. - Update the research report and release a new version. Through these efforts, the author hopes to support the international community's efforts to protect cultural heritage and provide basic data and methodological references for future responses to climate - related events.